Do Predation Rates on Artificial Nests Accurately Reflect Predation Rates on Natural Bird Nests
Year: 1999
Type: article
Abstract: Artificial nests are widely used in m4an field studies.However, it is unclear how well predation rates on artificial nests reflect predation rates on natural nests.Therefore, we compared survival rates of artificial nests (unused natural nests baited with House Sparrow eggs) with survival rates of active bird nests in the same habitat at the same sites.Survival rates of artificial nests (27.7%) were significantly lower than nest survival rates of natural nests (58.6%).Logistic regression analysis indicated that the inclusion of an index of nest concealment in addition to nest type (natural or artificial) significantly increased the amount of the variability in nest predation accounted for by the regression.However, because the relationship between nest survival and nest type (natural or artificial) was still highly significant even with nest concealment included in the model, we conclude that higher rates of nest predation on artificial nests were not entirely due to the greater conspicuousness of artificial nests.We suggest that lack of parental defense is an additional contributing factor responsible for higher predation rates on artificial nests and, therefore, is likely to be a potential confounding factor in future nest predation experiments using artificial nests.ES ACASO LA TASA DE DEPREDACION EN NIDOS ARTIFICIALES UN REFLEJO DE LA TASA DE DEPREDACI(SN EN NIDOS NATURALES?Sinopsis.--Losnidos artificiales son fimpliamente utilizandos en trabajos de campo.Sin embargo, no esta claro si la tasa de depredaci6n en nidos artificiales es un refiejo de la tasa de depredaci6n en nidos naturales.Por consiguiente, comparamos la tasa de supervivencia en nidos artificiales (nidos naturales sin utilizar en donde se colocaron huevos de gorri6n ingl•s) con la tasa de supervivencia de nidos activos en las mismas localidades yen el mismo tipo de habitat.E1 •xito de supervivencia de nidos artificiales (27.7%) fue significantivamente menor que la supervivencia de nidos naturales (58.6%).Un anfilisis de regresi6n log•stica indic6 que el incluir un indice de inconspicuidad, en adici6n al tipo de nido (natural o artificial), increment6 significativamente la cantidad de variabilidad de la depredaci6n de nidos contabilizados para la regresi6n.Sin embargo, debido a que la relaci6n entre la supervivencia y el tipo de nido rodavia era altamente significativa (inclusive incluyendo el grado de inconspicuidad en el modelo), concluimos que la alta tasa de depredaci6n en nidos artificiales no se debe en su totalidad al grado de conspicuidad de dichos nidos.Sugerimos que la ausencia de defenza parental o de la hembra en el nido con su plumaje criptico, puedan ser una contribuci6n adicional responsable para la mayor tasa de depredacion en nidos artificiales.
Source: Journal of Field Ornithology
Language: English
Topic: Avian ecology and behavior
Subfield: Ecology
Field: Environmental Science
Domain: Physical Sciences
SDG: Life on land
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W34571817
