Work

Formation, preservation and extinction of high-pressure minerals in meteorites: temperature effects in shock metamorphism and shock classification

Year: 2022
Type: article
Abstract: The goal of classifying shock metamorphic features in meteorites is to estimate the corresponding shock pressure conditions. However, the temperature variability of shock metamorphism is equally important and can result in a diverse and heterogeneous set of shock features in samples with a common overall shock pressure. In particular, high-pressure (HP) minerals, which were previously used as a solid indicator of high shock pressure in meteorites, require complex pressure–temperature–time ( P–T–t ) histories to form and survive. First, parts of the sample must be heated to melting temperatures, at high pressure, to enable rapid formation of HP minerals before pressure release. Second, the HP minerals must be rapidly cooled to below a critical temperature, before the pressure returns to ambient conditions, to avoid retrograde transformation to their low-pressure polymorphs. These two constraints require the sample to contain large temperature heterogeneities, e.g. melt veins in a cooler groundmass, during shock. In this study, we calculated shock temperatures and possible P–T paths of chondritic and differentiated mafic–ultramafic rocks for various shock pressures. These P–T conditions and paths, combined with observations from shocked meteorites, are used to constrain shock conditions and P–T – t histories of HP-mineral bearing samples. The need for rapid thermal quench of HP phases requires a relatively low bulk-shock temperature and therefore moderate shock pressures below ~ 30 GPa, which matches the stabilities of these HP minerals. The low-temperature moderate-pressure host rock generally shows moderate shock-deformation features consistent with S4 and, less commonly, S5 shock stages. Shock pressures in excess of 50 GPa in meteorites result in melt breccias with high overall post-shock temperatures that anneal out HP-mineral signatures. The presence of ringwoodite, which is commonly considered an indicator of the S6 shock stage, is inconsistent with pressures in excess of 30 GPa and does not represent shock conditions different from S4 shock conditions. Indeed, ringwoodite and coexisting HP minerals should be considered as robust evidence for moderate shock pressures (S4) rather than extreme shock (S6) near whole-rock melting.
Language: English
Open Access status: gold
Estimated APC paid: $1,690
Awards: SHOCK METAMORPHISM IN METEORITES RECORDS THE CONDITIONS OF PLANETARY IMPACTS THE RESETTING OF ISOTOPE GEOCHRONOMETERS AND THE DYNAMICS OF THE SOLAR SYSTEM. FELDSPAR IS ABUNDANT IN ORDINARY CHONDRITES AND MARTIAN METEORITES AND RECORDS SHOCK EVENTS THROUGH SEVERAL TRANSITIONS THAT ARE USED TO DEFINE PRESSURE (P) AND TEMPERATURE (T) FOR IMPACTS ON ASTEROIDS AND MARS. SHOCK EXPERIMENTS ON FELDSPAR THAT REPRODUCE THE OBSERVED SHOCK EFFECTS IN METEORITES ARE THE BASIS OF ATTEMPTS TO CALIBRATE THE PRESSURE SCALE. HOWEVER CHALLENGES ASSOCIATED WITH THESE EXPERIMENTS HAVE LEFT LINGERING QUESTIONS AND UNCERTAINTIES OF INTERPRETATION: 1) LABORATORY SHOCKS HAVE NOT YET RECOVERED MANY HIGH-PRESSURE (HP) PHASES FORMED BY TRANSFORMATION OF NATURALLY SHOCKED FELDSPAR INCLUDING JADEITE TISSINTITE LINGUNITE AND CAS/HAS. THIS IS LIKELY BECAUSE CLASSIC EXPERIMENTS ON MONOMINERALIC OR HOMOGENEOUS ROCK TARGETS DO NOT SAMPLE THE SAME P-T PATH AS NATURAL SHOCKS INTO POROUS REGOLITH TARGETS. 2) SHOCK EXPERIMENTS ON FELDSPAR AND BASALTS WERE MOSTLY DONE BEFORE 1990 WHEREAS IN-SITU NANO-ANALYSIS TECHNIQUES (FE-SEM EBSD AND FIB-TEM) HAVE BEEN DEVELOPED SINCE THEN. MANY NEW SHOCK-INDUCED MINERALS HAVE BEEN DISCOVERED BY NANO-SCALE STUDY OF METEORITES RECENTLY SUGGESTING THAT SHOCK RECOVERY EXPERIMENTS ALSO NEED TO BE REVISITED WITH MODERN ANALYTICAL TOOLS. 3) PRESSURE THRESHOLDS FOR EFFECTS SUCH AS PLANAR DEFORMATION FEATURES (PDF) AND MASKELYNIZATION ARE BASED MOSTLY ON EXPERIMENTS WITH MONOMINERALIC TARGETS. DIFFERENCES IN STARTING MATERIAL AND HENCE P-T PATH BETWEEN THE LAB AND NATURAL SHOCKS LIMIT THE ACCURACY OF PRESSURE CALIBRATION AND INDEED OUR PRELIMINARY SHOTS ON POROUS BASALT TARGETS REVEAL MASKELYNIZATION WELL BELOW THE NOMINAL THRESHOLD PRESSURE FOR THIS TRANSITION. ALTHOUGH SHOCK DURATION REMAINS A KEY LIMITATION OF LAB SHOCKS WE PROPOSE TO ADDRESS THESE QUESTIONS WITH A SEQUENCE OF 12 NOVEL EXPERIMENTS TO ACHIEVE P-T PATHS MORE COMPARABLE TO THOSE OF NATURAL SHOCKS. THE EXPERIMENTS TO BE EXTENSIVELY CHARACTERIZED AT NANO-SCALE WILL EXPLORE THE LIBRARY OF HP PHASES AFTER FELDSPAR AND PROVIDE MORE ACCURATE PRESSURE CALIBRATION FOR PROGRESSIVE SHOCK EFFECTS: 1) GRADED DENSITY IMPACTORS PROVIDE FAST BUT COLD COMPRESSION PATHS CLOSE TO THE ISENTROPE A COMPRESSION METHOD NOT YET APPLIED TO RECOVERY EXPERIMENTS. HAVING A SHOCK PULSE LONGER THAN THE THERMAL PULSE PREVENTS POST-SHOCK ANNEALING AND PROMOTES RECOVERY OF HP PHASES. COMPRESSION WITH MINIMAL IRREVERSIBLE HEATING IS ONE PATH TO ACHIEVING QUENCH BY RECOVERING MATERIAL DIRECTLY TO AMBIENT TEMPERATURE. 2) SAMPLES WITH MACHINED PORES CREATE LOCAL HOT SPOTS BY PORE COLLAPSE DURING SHOCK. THE HOT SPOT MAY BE NECESSARY TO ENHANCE DIFFUSION ENCOURAGE PARTIAL MELTING AND CATALYZE HP TRANSFORMATIONS. THE SMALL SIZE OF THE HOT SPOT ENCOURAGES QUENCH BY CONDUCTION INTO SURROUNDING COLDER MATERIAL. 3) OBLIQUE IMPACTS IN WHICH DIFFERENT PARTICLE VELOCITIES ACROSS MATERIAL INTERFACES INDUCE DYNAMIC SLIDING AND SHEAR. DEVIATORIC STRESS DURING SHOCK CAN CHANGE TRANSFORMATION PRESSURES AND MANY NATURAL HP MINERALS ARE ASSOCIATED WITH SHEAR VEINS IN METEORITES. 4) MARTIAN ANALOGUE ROCKS WITH VARIABLE POROSITY DIFFER FROM FULLY DENSE SAMPLES AND HOMOGENEOUS ROCK POWDERS. PRELIMINARY EXPERIMENTS ON BASALT YIELD MASKELYNITE AT LOWER P THAN IN SINGLE CRYSTAL OR POWDER EXPERIMENTS. THE PROPOSED EXPERIMENTS WILL CONFIRM THE SHOCK ORIGIN OF OBSERVED HP MINERALS FROM FELDSPAR IN METEORITES AND PROVIDE MORE ACCURATE PRESSURE CALIBRATION. THE EXPERIMENTS ARE LIKELY ALSO TO REVEAL SHOCK EFFECTS IN OTHER ROCK-FORMING MINERALS AND TERRESTRIAL IMPACT STRUCTURES. THE NEW CALIBRATION RESULTS WILL BE USED TO PROVIDE A P-T SCHEMATIC FOR PROGRESSIVE SHOCK EFFECTS IN CHONDRITES AND MARTIAN METEORITES FOR BETTER INTERPRETING THEIR GEOCHRONOLOGY AND BETTER CONSTRAINING PARAMETERS OF IMPACTS ON ASTEROIDS AND MARS BOTH SUBJECTS OF DIRECT RELEVANCE TO THE SCOPE OF SOLAR SYSTEM WORKINGS., G507870099, Shock Wave Studies of Liquids in Earth's Core and Mantle, G6291763926
OpenAlex ID: W4225317604
FWCI: 5.167
Cites: 139
Cited by: 64
Related to: 10