Work

State Power to Prohibit Interstate Commerce

Year: 1937
Type: article
Abstract: F ALL the opinions, monographs, treatises and articles which have been written concerning the commerce clause of the Federal Constitution were laid end to end, they would reach from confusion to futility.An excuse seems the natural preface to adding further discussion of the subject.In the present case, that excuse is furnished by the recent ruling' of the Supreme Court that a state, with (and possibly without) the consent of Congress, can forbid the sale of harmless articles because of the conditions under which they were manufactured in another state, and a subsequent decision that the national government can forbid the interstate transportation of such goods. 2These new developments would seem to rock the doctrine supposedly established by the first Child Labor CaseO to its very foundations, and warrant a reexamination of the record in an attempt to formulate anew, in the light of the evidence now available, the basic principles which control the answers to the questions: When, and by whom, may interstate commerce be prohibited?Prior to the adoption of the Constitution interstate commerce was a branch of foreign commerce, each state enjoying full authority to tax, restrict, or prohibit it at pleasure.And it has been said that "None of that power was abridged by that instrument except as restrained by constitutional safeguards, and hence none was lost by the adoption of the Constitution.The Constitution, whilst distributing the preexisting authority, preserved it all."4 If this be true, power to forbid interstate commerce must now be vested either in Congress or the state legislatures, or both, except in so far as it is restricted by "constitutional safeguards" found in the body of the Constitution or the amendments.This need not imply that arbitrary power to prohibit interstate commerce still exists in either the national or state governments.With the 1 Whitfield v. Ohio (1936) 297 U. S. 431, holding that Ohio can make criminal the sale of work shirts manufactured by prison labor in Alabama.2 Kentucky Whip and Collar Co. v.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W4232186474
FWCI: 19.59
Cites:
Cited by: 2
Related to: 10