Border Matters: Redefining the National Interest in U.S.-Mexico Immigration and Trade Policy
Year: 2004
Type: article
Abstract: U.S.-Mexico immigration and trade policies have developed independently, both pointing to "the national interest" as a guiding principle loosely defined by economic-welfare maximization.Meanwhile, the policies materially interact to affect border peoples by creating or exacerbating such harms as immigrant smuggling, vigilante justice, and civil rights and labor violations.This Comment criticizes the trade-immigration separation and catalogues the resulting border conditions.It argues that the separation of trade and immigration likely stems not simply from economic rationales, but from an understanding of the national interest grounded in nativistic racism and a conception of the nation that excludes border peoples.This Comment offers nativistic racism as an underlying, but dominant, national value that undercuts effective U.S. border policy and maintains the unrealistic separation of trade and immigration policies.Finally, this Comment assesses the likelihood of curing the ills described through traditional legal or policymaking approaches, ultimately calling for a redefinition of the national interest.1.
Source: California Law Review
DOI: 10.2307/3481354
Author: Gabriela A. Gallegos
Language: English
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W4232829661
