Book Review: Political Thought in Medieval Times, The King's two Bodies. A Study in Medieval Political Theology, The Idea of a Social Science, World without War, Free Elections, Marginal Seat, 1955: A Study of Voting Behaviour in the Constituency of Bristol North East at the General Election of 1955, Small Town Politics. A Study of Political Life in Glossop, The Supreme Court as Final Arbiter in Federal-State Relations, 1789–1957, Rhode Island Politics and the American Revolution, 1760–1776, Dimensions of Congressional Voting. A Statistical Survey of the House of Representatives in the Eighty-First Congress, La Fonction Publique Aux États-Unis, Government Administration in New Zealand
Year: 1959
Type: book-review
Abstract: Mr.Morrall attempts what he himself calls 'a general sketch of the political thought of the Middle Ages' in, effectively, 128 pages.It is no light undertaking.Any writer on medieval political thought who has a non-specialist audience in view must spend a lot of time explaining what he is writing about.Mr. Morrall must devote two chapters and fully a seventh of his space to preliminary elucidations of such topics as the fall of the Roman Empire, the nature of the early Church, and the structure of feudal society.And the elucidatory task is 'always doing and never done': there must later be explanations of the revival of Roman Law, the 'renaissance' of the twelfth century, the effect of Aristotle on thirteenth-century thought.Then, when all the explanations are over, there remains a concept of society so different from most of our own working notions that, in comparison with most medieval discussions of political problems, Plato's Republic may seem almost vulgarly modern.Yet the evolution of modern politics and political speculation cannot really be understood if we leap over the centuries between Seneca and Machiavelli.If we are to comprehend either the gulf between medieval and modem politics or the elements of continuity between them we must in some measure 'get inside' the political mind of the Middle Ages.To that complex structure Mr. Morrall's work forms an introductory guide-book.The introduction is performed with considerable skill and a large measure of success.This book is a better general guide to a difficult subject than has hitherto existed.If faults are to be found, it is with what may seem to be a certain disproportion in the book's structure.Marsiglio of Padua, for example, is a fascinating writer, but surely, in his period, a somewhat eccentric one.Does he really deserve, in this context, a whole chapter to himself-fourteen pages, while Aquinas receives nine in a chapter which must also cover the rest of the thirteenth century?Still more striking is the contrasting treatment of Marsiglio and Ockham.The latter is no doubt, as Mr. Morrall says, 'bafffingly obscure'.But he is (one would have thought) important enough to merit more than two or three scattered references, amounting in all to no more than two pages.Indeed, the whole chapter-on 'The Age of Ambiguity'-in which these references occur clearly reveals the structural defect in the book.If the medieval period is taken as beginning effectively, for the purpose of studying its political thought, with the Investiture Contest of the eleventh century (and Mr. Morrall says very little about the earlier period) and as ending with the Reformation, then it seems unreasonable to dismiss the last two centuries of that period in a single chapter.It may be that the disproportion here complained of could not be set right within the limits of so short a book.If so, it must be concluded that the book is too short; and this indeed appears to be the case.Within its limits the book largely succeeds.The style is at times rather gauche, and more careful proof-reading would have removed some oddities in spelling and the like.There is a useful bibliography, with critical comments on the principal works cited.
Source: Political Studies
Language: English
Subfield: History
Field: Arts and Humanities
Domain: Social Sciences
Keywords: medieval political thought, political theology, king's two bodies, voting behavior, 1955 general election, small-town politics, Supreme Court, federal-state relations, Rhode Island politics, American Revolution, congressional voting, House of Representatives, public administration, New Zealand government
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W4244448321
