Year: 2005
Type: letter
Abstract: trial, it is impossible to decide whether any trial, it is impossible to decide whether any public health benefit has resulted from public health benefit has resulted from introducing psychiatric screening.Given introducing psychiatric screening.Given the weakness of the individual predictor the weakness of the individual predictor variables, the timing of screening (at the variables, the timing of screening (at the end of adolescence) and the fact that to date end of adolescence) and the fact that to date no programme of psychiatric screening for no programme of psychiatric screening for events that have yet to happen (i.e.future events that have yet to happen (i.e.future breakdown) has been shown to be effective breakdown) has been shown to be effective in a randomised controlled trial, I think in a randomised controlled trial, I think that I am entitled to stay with my conclu-that I am entitled to stay with my conclusions that psychiatric screening to detect sions that psychiatric screening to detect vulnerability to future breakdown remains vulnerability to future breakdown remains unproven and continues to have the poten-unproven and continues to have the potential to do more harm than good.Until such tial to do more harm than good.Until such evidence is forthcoming, it may be more evidence is forthcoming, it may be more useful to devote resources to increasing resi-useful to devote resources to increasing resilience through support and training, and lience through support and training, and providing better and more acceptable ser-providing better and more acceptable services to help those who do succumb to the vices to help those who do succumb to the rigours of military life.rigours of military life.
Authors: M. Isohanni, K. Moilanen
Institutions: University of Fukui, University of Oulu
Language: English
Subfield: Psychiatry and Mental health
Field: Medicine
Domain: Health Sciences
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W4251925186
