Year: 2022
Type: article
Abstract: Meta-analysis is pervasively used to combine multiple genome-wide association studies (GWAS) into a more powerful whole. To resolve causal variants, meta-analysis studies typically apply summary statistics-based fine-mapping methods as they are applied to single-cohort studies. However, it is unclear whether heterogeneous characteristics of each cohort ( e . g ., ancestry, sample size, phenotyping, genotyping, or imputation) affect fine-mapping calibration and recall. Here, we first demonstrate that meta-analysis fine-mapping is substantially miscalibrated in simulations when different genotyping arrays or imputation panels are included. To mitigate these issues, we propose a summary statistics-based QC method, SLALOM, that identifies suspicious loci for meta-analysis fine-mapping by detecting outliers in association statistics based on ancestry-matched local LD structure. Having validated SLALOM performance in simulations and the GWAS Catalog, we applied it to 14 disease endpoints from the Global Biobank Meta-analysis Initiative and found that 67% of loci showed suspicious patterns that call into question fine-mapping accuracy. These predicted suspicious loci were significantly depleted for having likely causal variants, such as nonsynonymous variants, as a lead variant (2.7x; Fisher’s exact P = 7.3 × 10 −4 ). Compared to fine-mapping results in individual biobanks, we found limited evidence of fine-mapping improvement in the GBMI meta-analyses. Although a full solution requires complete synchronization across cohorts, our approach identifies likely spurious results in meta-analysis fine-mapping. We urge extreme caution when interpreting fine-mapping results from meta-analysis.
Source: Cell Genomics
Authors: Masahiro Kanai, Masahiro Kanai, Roy Elzur, Wei Zhou, Wei Zhou, Masahiro Kanai, Masahiro Kanai, Kuan-Han H. Wu, Humaira Rasheed, Kristin Tsuo, Jibril B. Hirbo, Ying Wang, Arjun Bhattacharya, Huiling Zhao, Shinichi Namba, Ida Surakka, Brooke N. Wolford, Valeria Lo Faro, Esteban A. Lopera-Maya, Kristi Läll, Marie-Julie Favé, Juulia J. Partanen, Sinéad B. Chapman, Juha Karjalainen, Mitja Kurki, Mutaamba Maasha, Ben M. Brumpton, Sameer Chavan, Tzu-Ting Chen, Michelle Daya, Yi Ding, Yen-Chen A. Feng, Lindsay A. Guare, Christopher R. Gignoux, Sarah E. Graham, Whitney E. Hornsby, Nathan Ingold, Said I. Ismail, Ruth Johnson, Triin Laisk, Kuang Lin, Jun Lv, Iona Y. Millwood, Sonia Moreno-Grau, Kisung Nam, Priit Palta, Anita Pandit, Michael H. Preuss, Chadi Saad, Shefali Setia-Verma, Unnur Thorsteinsdottir, Jasmina Uzunovic, Anurag Verma, Matthew Zawistowski, Xue Zhong, Nahla Afifi, Kawthar M. Al-Dabhani, Asma Al Thani, Yuki Bradford, Archie Campbell, Kristy Crooks, Geertruida H. de Bock, Scott M. Damrauer, Nicholas J. Douville, Sarah Finer, Lars G. Fritsche, Eleni Fthenou, Gilberto Gonzalez-Arroyo, Christopher J. Griffiths, Yu Guo, Karen A. Hunt, Alexander Ioannidis, Nomdo M. Jansonius, Takahiro Konuma, Ming Ta Michael Lee, Arturo Lopez-Pineda, Yuta Matsuda, Riccardo E. Marioni, Babak Moatamed, Marco A. Nava-Aguilar, Kensuke Numakura, Snehal Patil, Nicholas Rafaels, Anne Richmond, Agustin Rojas-Muñoz, Jonathan A. Shortt, Peter Straub, Ran Tao, Brett Vanderwerff, Manvi Vernekar, Yogasudha Veturi, Kathleen C. Barnes, Marike Boezen, Zhengming Chen, Chia-Yen Chen, Judy Cho, George Davey Smith, Hilary K. Finucane, Lude Franke, Eric R. Gamazon, Andrea Ganna, Tom R. Gaunt, Tian Ge, Hailiang Huang, Jennifer Huffman, Nicholas Katsanis, Jukka T. Koskela, Clara Lajonchere, Matthew H. Law, Liming Li, Cecilia M. Lindgren, Ruth J.F. Loos, Stuart MacGregor, Koichi Matsuda, Catherine M. Olsen, David J. Porteous, Jordan A. Shavit, Harold Snieder, Tomohiro Takano, Richard C. Trembath, Judith M. Vonk, David C. Whiteman, Stephen J. Wicks, Cisca Wijmenga, John Wright, Jie Zheng, Xiang Zhou, Philip Awadalla, Michael Boehnke, Carlos D. Bustamante, Nancy J. Cox, Segun Fatumo, Daniel H. Geschwind, Caroline Hayward, Kristian Hveem, Eimear E. Kenny, Seunggeun Lee, Yen-Feng Lin, Hamdi Mbarek, Reedik Mägi, Hilary C. Martin, Sarah E. Medland, Yukinori Okada, Aarno V. Palotie, Bogdan Pasaniuc, Daniel J. Rader, Marylyn D. Ritchie, Serena Sanna, Jordan W. Smoller, Kari Stefansson, David A. van Heel, Robin G. Walters, Sebastian Zöllner, Biobank of the Americas, Biobank Japan Project, BioMe, BioVU, CanPath - Ontario Health Study, China Kadoorie Biobank Collaborative Group, Colorado Center for Personalized Medicine, deCODE Genetics, Estonian Biobank, FinnGen, Generation Scotland, LifeLines, Mass General Brigham Biobank, Michigan Genomics Initiative, National Biobank of Korea, Penn Medicine BioBank, Qatar Biobank, The Qskin Sun and Health Study, Taiwan Biobank, The Hunt Study, Ucla Atlas Community Health Initiative, Uganda Genome Resource, Uk Biobank, Alicia R. Martin, Cristen J. Willer, Mark J. Daly, Benjamin M. Neale, Mark J. Daly, Hilary K. Finucane
Language: English
Subfield: Genetics
Domain: Life Sciences
Open Access status: gold
Estimated APC paid: $8,900
OpenAlex ID: W4308174398