Author response: The Candida albicans virulence factor candidalysin polymerizes in solution to form membrane pores and damage epithelial cells
Year: 2022
Type: peer-review
Abstract: Article Figures and data Abstract Editor's evaluation eLife digest Introduction Results Discussion Materials and methods Data availability References Decision letter Author response Article and author information Metrics Abstract Candida albicans causes severe invasive candidiasis. C. albicans infection requires the virulence factor candidalysin (CL) which damages target cell membranes. However, the mechanism that CL uses to permeabilize membranes is unclear. We reveal that CL forms membrane pores using a unique mechanism. Unexpectedly, CL readily assembled into polymers in solution. We propose that the basic structural unit in polymer formation is a CL oligomer, which is sequentially added into a string configuration that can close into a loop. CL loops appear to spontaneously insert into the membrane to become pores. A CL mutation (G4W) inhibited the formation of polymers in solution and prevented pore formation in synthetic lipid systems. Epithelial cell studies showed that G4W CL failed to activate the danger response pathway, a hallmark of the pathogenic effect of CL. These results indicate that CL polymerization in solution is a necessary step for the damage of cellular membranes. Analysis of CL pores by atomic force microscopy revealed co-existence of simple depressions and more complex pores, which are likely formed by CL assembled in an alternate oligomer orientation. We propose that this structural rearrangement represents a maturation mechanism that stabilizes pore formation to achieve more robust cellular damage. To summarize, CL uses a previously unknown mechanism to damage membranes, whereby pre-assembly of CL loops in solution leads to formation of membrane pores. Our investigation not only unravels a new paradigm for the formation of membrane pores, but additionally identifies CL polymerization as a novel therapeutic target to treat candidiasis. Editor's evaluation This study by Russell et al. reveals interesting details of the mechanism of pore formation of a newly identified peptide toxin secreted by Candida albicans (candidalysin). Using atomic force microscopy along with other techniques, the authors demonstrate that pre-assembly of polymers in solution is the first step in the formation of permeabilizing pores, and identify an intriguing inactive mutant. This manuscript will be of interest to several fields, in particular to microbiologists and structural biologists studying pore forming proteins and peptides. https://doi.org/10.7554/eLife.75490.sa0 Decision letter Reviews on Sciety eLife's review process eLife digest The fungus Candida albicans is the most common cause of yeast infections in humans. Like many other disease-causing microbes, it releases several virulent proteins that invade and damage human cells. This includes the peptide candidalysin which has been shown to be crucial for infection. Human cells are surrounded by a protective membrane that separates their interior from their external environment. Previous work showed that candidalysin damages the cell membrane to promote infection. However, how candidalysin does this remained unclear. Similar peptides and proteins cause harm by inserting themselves into the membrane and then grouping together to form a ring. This creates a hole, or ‘pore’, that weakens the membrane and allows other molecules into the cell’s interior. Here, Russell, Schaefer et al. show that candidalysin uses a unique pore forming mechanism to impair the membrane of human cells. A combination of biophysical and cell biology techniques revealed that the peptide groups together to form a chain. This chain of candidalysin proteins then closes in on itself to create a loop structure that can insert into the membrane to form a pore. Once embedded within the membrane, the proteins within the loops rearrange again to make the pores more stable so they can cause greater damage. This type of pore formation has not been observed before, and may open up new avenues of research. For instance, researchers could use this information to develop inhibitors that stop candidalysin from forming chains and harming the membranes of cells. This could help treat the infections caused by C. albicans. Introduction Fungal infections are responsible for high morbidity burden around the world (Brown et al., 2012). Candida albicans is one of the most serious fungal threats to human health. This pathogen is part of the commensal flora, but can infect the skin, mouth, vagina, and gut, both in healthy and immunocompromised individuals. Additionally, C. albicans causes invasive candidiasis, an infection of the blood, heart, and other organs, which is common in hospitalized patients (Kullberg and Arendrup, 2015). Invasive candidiasis causes high rates of mortality (~50%), even when patients are treated with antifungal therapy (Kullberg and Arendrup, 2015). It has been recently discovered that C. albicans causes toxicity by secreting onto the surface of epithelial cells a peptide toxin named candidalysin (CL) (Moyes et al., 2016). This virulence factor binds to the plasma membrane of target human epithelial cells and compromises the permeability barrier, causing uncontrolled Ca2+ influx and release of cellular proteins on to the extracellular medium (Naglik et al., 2019). The resulting cellular damage activates a signaling cascade that triggers the release of pro-inflammatory mediators (Naglik et al., 2019; Richardson et al., 2018b), which participate in the immune response to C. albicans infection. Furthermore, CL plays a second pathogenic role, as it also attacks the membrane of mononuclear phagocytes which would otherwise fight the fungal infection (Kasper et al., 2018). CL is necessary for infection by C. albicans (Liu et al., 2021). Therefore, pharmacological inhibition of CL activity is a promising avenue to fight infection of this human pathogen. However, the development of drugs to counter the action of CL is hampered by the lack of understanding of how this peptide damages membranes. Here, we describe how the use of biophysical techniques (mass photometry, native mass spectrometry, analytical ultracentrifugation, transmission electron microscopy, atomic force microscopy, oriented circular dichroism, and liposome dye release assay), modeling, and cellular assays allowed us to elucidate that CL damages membranes by forming pores that are assembled through a unique molecular mechanism. Results CL assembles into polymers in solution When we ran CL on an SDS-PAGE, we observed not only the expected monomeric band running at ~4 kDa, but also a band of slower electrophoretic mobility (Figure 1A). This result suggests that CL self-assembles in solution, and we hypothesized that this event might be related to its ability to damage cellular membranes. We therefore investigated CL oligomerization, first using native ion mobility-mass spectrometry (IM-MS), a sensitive analytical technique that can isolate and characterize transient oligomers based on their mass-to-charge ratio (m/z), shape, size, and charge. IM-MS analysis of CL revealed several oligomeric species (Figure 1B). The mass spectral peak at m/z 3311, which corresponds to a nominal oligomer-to-charge ratio (n/z) of 1/1, was notable due to its high intensity when compared to the surrounding oligomers. Analysis of the arrival time distributions (ATD) of this mass spectral peak (Figure 1C) revealed two features that correspond to higher-order CL oligomers. We conservatively assigned the longest arrival time feature (salmon) as an 8-mer with z = +8. This assignment was performed comparing the isotopic spacing and drift time of the features within the ATD with other mass spectral peaks (see Figure 1—figure supplement 1). Since a species with a high charge will travel faster than one with a lower charge, the fastest arrival time species (green) is proposed to be a large oligomer resulting from the self-assembly of the 8-mer. The ATD data therefore suggest that CL forms an 8-mer that self-assembles. Given that CL adopts helical structure in solution (Moyes et al., 2016), we built an atomistic model of the 8-mer by aligning CL’s sequence into the eight-helix coiled coil formed by CC-Type2-II (PDB ID 6G67). After the resulting structure was energy minimized (Figure 1—figure supplement 1), the theoretical collisional cross-section of the model, 2500 Å2, agreed with the experimental value of 2567 Å2. Figure 1 with 2 supplements see all Download asset Open asset CL forms complex assemblies in solution. (A) SDS-PAGE of CL shows a~4 kDa monomeric band, and a band corresponding to a large oligomer. Molecular weight markers are shown on the left. (B) IM-MS mass spectrum of CL annotated with oligomer-to-charge (n/z) ratios. The inset spectrum reveals oligomers that are not immediately identifiable in the top spectrum. (C) Arrival time distribution of the 8-mer (n/z=1/1) species. This peak was more populated than those corresponding to smaller oligomers, which might result from decomposition of the 8-mer in the gas phase. The experimental collisional cross section for the single 8-mer (highlighted in salmon) is given. (D) Analytical ultracentrifugation data identifies populations of increasingly larger CL oligomers. (E) Mass photometry data of CL oligomeric species. The green area marks the approximate mass range (<50 kDa) below the resolution of the technique. Data distribution was best fit with six Gaussian populations (shown as blue lines, and summary fit is the black line). The mass of the peaks agree with the expected mass for 2, 3, 4, 8, 13, and 22 CL 8-mers (similar to a Fibonacci sequence). Figure 1—source data 1 Original SDS-PAGE gel corresponding to Figure 1A. https://cdn.elifesciences.org/articles/75490/elife-75490-fig1-data1-v1.zip Download elife-75490-fig1-data1-v1.zip Figure 1—source data 2 Raw mass photometry data corresponding to Figure 1E. https://cdn.elifesciences.org/articles/75490/elife-75490-fig1-data2-v1.zip Download elife-75490-fig1-data2-v1.zip We used two additional biophysical methods to confirm and further investigate CL oligomerization in solution. We first performed analytical ultracentrifugation of CL (Figure 1D). The sedimentation velocity results reveal a low sedimentation peak, likely corresponding to a CL monomer, and several larger assemblies, in agreement with the IM-MS data analysis. We next used mass photometry (MP), a technique that allows mass determination of biomolecules with single-molecule resolution from their combined light scattering and reflection signature (Asor and Kukura, 2022). While MP is insensitive to the mass of an CL 8-mer (26.5 kDa), as the resolution of the instrument is limited to particles >50 kDa, MP has high sensitivity to larger species. Figure 1E displays MP data of CL, consisting of a main peak and a long tail. The main peak agrees with the mass of two bound 8-mers, while the larger mass peaks would correspond to the progressive assembly of 8-mers (see Figure 1—figure supplement 2). The long tail of the MP data reaches beyond 600 kDa, which would correspond to the assembly of tens of 8-mers. Taken together, the four techniques reveal that CL readily forms large oligomers in solution and suggest that the 8-mer is the seed for CL self-assembly into large structures. We employed microscopy to resolve the assemblies that CL forms in solution. We first performed negative-stain transmission electron microscopy (TEM), and observed that CL does not form amorphous aggregates, but instead assembles into linear structures (Figure 2A). The TEM data revealed a basic structural unit, which seemed to grow in a step-wise fashion into polymers (Figure 2A, side panels). The longer polymers curved, and in some cases closed in on themselves, forming a loop with diameter ≥10 nm. We further studied CL polymerization by atomic force microscopy (AFM) since this technique provides high resolution images of single particles and can also be readily used to image membrane pores (Dufrêne et al., 2017). AFM images of CL adsorbed onto mica in buffer (Figure 2B) agreed with the TEM results and confirmed that CL polymerizes and can form loops. The bending stiffness of CL polymers was calculated from AFM images through persistence length, Lp, analysis (Lp = 9 nm±2 nm, N=100, Figure 2—figure supplement 1). The bending stiffness of linear CL polymers is significantly lower than other biological polymers, like actin fibers (Gittes et al., 1993), explaining the ability of CL polymers to close into loops. Figure 2 with 3 supplements see all Download asset Open asset CL in solution forms progressively longer linear polymers and loops. (A) TEM reveals CL polymerization; scale bar = 100 nm. Features of growing complexity are magnified in the side panels; scale bar = 10 nm. (B) AFM imaging in fluid shows overall agreement with TEM data; scale bar = 100 nm. Four similar CL features are also highlighted in the side panels; scale bar = 10 nm. (C) Smoothed volume histogram of N=7838 individual features (solid black line) fitted with Gaussian distributions (solid colored lines, summary fit is the gray dashed line). The inset compares the experimental volume of the first four peaks (squares colored as in panel C) with simulated volumes (black diamonds) calculated from N 8-mers. The cartoon shows an example of head-to-toe assembly of two 8-mers. Error bars for the peak positions represent the standard deviation. (D) When the height of the individual features was measured, it yielded a bimodal distribution, with heights of 3.2 nm and 4.6 nm. The insets show the two proposed orientations of the 8-mer. The topographic surface is overlaid to show convolution of the AFM tip. Examination of AFM images containing thousands of particles yielded a volume distribution with a sharp peak and a long tail (Figure 2C), which resembles the distribution observed in the MP data (Figure 1E). Such agreement suggests that the AFM results are robust and are not caused by spurious interactions with the AFM tip. The AFM volume histogram was deconvolved by fitting Gaussian distributions, revealing a primary peak and several larger sub-populations of larger volumes (Figure 2C). The volume increased in approximately constant steps between the populations (see side panels of Figure 2B), confirming that a basic intermediate oligomer grew first by dimerization, followed by sequential addition to further increase linear polymer length. We measured the height of the individual particles observed by AFM, and the resulting histogram (Figure 2D) yielded two peaks, with heights of 3.2±0.4 nm and 4.6±0.5 nm. We reasoned that the bimodal height distribution could indicate two orientations (vertical and horizontal) of the basic structural unit that serves as an intermediate oligomer (Figure 2B inset, labeled ‘1’), which is probably the CL 8-mer identified by IM-MS (Figure 1B, Figure 2—figure supplement 2). We tested this possibility by using the CL 8-mer model (Figure 1—figure supplement 1) to generate simulated AFM images through morphological dilation of the estimated tip geometry for the 8-mer, either on its horizontal or vertical orientations (Figure 2D, insets). We found good agreement between the simulation [heights of 3.3 nm and 4.8 nm] and the two experimental peaks shown in Figure 2D. Interestingly, the volume of the modeled 8-mer in the horizontal orientation additionally agrees within uncertainty with the value of the basic AFM structural unit (Figure 2C inset). Taken together, these results support the notion that CL assembles into an 8-mer in solution that acts as an intermediate step in the self-assembly process. Polymer growth of CL 8-mers in the horizontal orientation (lying flat on a surface) can occur by addition of a second 8-mer in two fundamental modes, side-by-side or head-to-toe. When we modeled the latter arrangement for the assembly of two, three, and four head-to-toe 8-mers (Figure 2C, inset), we found agreement between the simulated and experimental AFM volumes (Figure 2C, inset; Figure 2—figure supplement 3). Taken together, the data indicate that a CL polymer is formed when a basic subunit, which our results suggest is an 8-mer, is aligned in the longest dimension, and grows by sequential head-to-toe addition of additional subunits. CL forms two classes of membrane pores CL mediates C. albicans infection by damaging the integrity of the plasma membrane of human cells (Moyes et al., 2016). It has been proposed that CL forms membrane pores (Moyes et al., 2016), but such structures have never been observed. We performed AFM imaging on supported lipid bilayers made of DOPC (1,2-dioleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine) to gain insights into how CL causes membrane disruption. We observed that in the presence of CL, bilayers indeed exhibited punctate depressions commonly associated with pores (Figure 3A). Though the AFM tip is sharp (nominal radius ~8 nm), the pores’ radii were often smaller than the tip, preventing passage all the way through the 4-nm-thick membrane, which cause artificially shallow readings (Pittman et al., 2018; Schaefer et al., 2022; Figure 3—figure supplement 1). Figure 3 with 3 supplements see all Download asset Open asset CL forms two types of membrane pores. Representative images showing predominantly unrimmed (A) and rimmed (B) pore features in supported DOPC membranes; scale bars = 100 nm. The insets show zoomed views of green boxed features; scale bars = 10 nm. (C) Area histograms show that unrimmed pores (gray line) display a broad peak at 41±25 nm2 (mean ± S.D.) with a shoulder at ~130 nm2, similar to loops found in solution (38±21 nm2, aqua blue line). In contrast, the rimmed pores (black line) exhibit a narrower distribution with a smaller area (26±19 nm2) (Nunrimmed pores = 1468, Nrimmed pores = 492, Nloops = 261). (D) Unrimmed (top) and rimmed (bottom) features were imaged over several minutes; scale bars = 10 nm. (E) Line scans, marked as white in the show the of the pore in both were used for The and as the standard of the by are The CL pores into two broad simple depressions (Figure and complex pores surrounded by a of of an approximate height of nm the surface (Figure To between the two types of pores, they are to as (Figure and (Figure pores, types of pores were to in the (Figure 3—figure supplement that CL is not by interactions with the mica rimmed and unrimmed pores were observed in the image area (Figure 3—figure supplement that in imaging were not responsible for the between rimmed and unrimmed pores have a smaller area than unrimmed pores (Figure Unrimmed pores have a broad area distribution, with the main at nm2 (Figure while the rimmed pores have a narrower distribution, and an area peak at nm2 (Figure of the were imaged to a time of both unrimmed and rimmed pores. A unrimmed pore (Figure top shows with large over The pore between and shallow the other the rimmed pore (Figure and is more as shown by the constant over time (Figure While the two types of pores are likely to cause membrane we propose that the presence of the the pore with increased which could be a mechanism to CL pores with membrane damaging CL polymers insert into the membrane, and loops become membrane pores We that were between the and of the loops that CL forms in the of membrane and the unrimmed membrane pores (Figure blue and gray This agreement us to that CL loops could insert into membranes and become unrimmed pores. We could this as a of supported would spontaneously from the mica surface (Figure imaging the area we observed features similar to the CL polymers and loops in the of lipid often were observed pores were previously (see blue features similar to the CL polymers observed for solution were also which been previously by the presence of a This that linear polymers can insert into membranes causing membrane but when they close into a loop they form an unrimmed membrane pore. Figure with 1 supplement see all Download asset Open asset CL polymers and loops insert into membranes. (A) features from the mica revealing structures similar to CL polymers in solution Figure scale bars = nm. indicate pore features and corresponding polymer features were revealed that were not previously observed when lipid was A green to a feature that in both as a (B) was used to lipid The addition of followed by revealed CL structures. bars = 100 nm. (C) A histogram of heights compares data of CL adsorbed in solution to the features addition of to the CL The results were two overall 8-mer The features of the membrane exhibited a broad peak both of the solution In to these in a we used the to the lipid et al., et al., Once the and lipid were the CL structures were imaged (Figure showed that DOPC molecules from the mica but not the CL polymers (Figure supplement our data suggest that might the of polymers that close into a loop (Figure supplement 1). The histogram in Figure reveals between the height of CL features adsorbed to mica in solution, showing a bimodal and in membrane In these latter was a of the primary height peak, which can be to between CL and the However, the increase in features could also be an that the vertical 8-mer orientation (Figure 2D) is in the presence of lipid membranes. Our data indicate that loops can insert into membranes and form unrimmed pores. These might into the rimmed pores, which have The then head-to-toe or does the CL 8-mer in the two types of pores. To investigate this we modeled loops of N in the two 8-mer head-to-toe and side-by-side (Figure between the experimental and the (Figure Figure supplement 1) suggest that the loops found in solution, similar to the linear polymers, into a head-to-toe The loop would be of six head-to-toe 8-mers, for a mass kDa) that corresponds with the of the tail in the MP distribution (Figure 1E). Figure with 1 supplement see all Download asset Open asset pores appear a (A) CL pores were simulated using two of the 8-mer subunit, side-by-side (green) and head-to-toe The area is the of subunits. The insets show for in both loops with were not The side panel shows the experimental for unrimmed pores (gray rimmed pores and the loops found in solution bars represent standard deviation. A cartoon which are the loop area (top) and the pore area (B) circular of CL in buffer and in the presence of lipid (C) data in supported membranes for CL and G4W The inset shows theoretical for a or an aligned to the membrane We further studied CL membrane by the features that remained lipid (Figure For unrimmed pores, the AFM data also to a head-to-toe 8-mer arrangement (Figure with a side-by-side orientation were in the solution but were common in CL that been to between the model and the rimmed pores data suggest that in these pores the 8-mers from the head-to-toe orientation found in the unrimmed pores (gray side panel of Figure to a side-by-side orientation (black the modeled that unrimmed pores six to head-to-toe 8-mers, while rimmed pores are formed by six to 8-mers. Therefore, we propose that a rimmed pore (Figure when the 8-mer in an unrimmed pore from the head-to-toe to the side-by-side arrangement insets in Figure We the results of the using circular Figure shows that CL as expected (Moyes et al., 2016), an structure in solution, as by the spectral at and nm. We also observed that the presence of lipid additional by growth of the and its The orientation of the CL with to the membrane can be using oriented which is performed using supported lipid membranes et al., 2019). can between aligned along the membrane and et al., Figure inset). The data of CL low and a at nm and a at nm, to the expected result for et al., 2018; et al., 2021). The spectrum therefore that the orientation of in CL in membranes was the membrane, in a orientation. This is the proposed helical that is expected in the side-by-side 8-mer arrangement of the rimmed pores. However, the presence of a at nm agrees with the presence of a of oriented along the of the membrane, like those expected for the unrimmed pore. Therefore, the result the presence of a combination of rimmed and unrimmed CL pores with the helical orientations by the AFM analysis of CL provides insights Our experimental data and indicate that CL 8-mers in solution in a head-to-toe We to further this by in the CL A head-to-toe assembly of a helical between the helical of an 8-mer with the of the (Figure supplement 1). Our 8-mer model that the is at (Figure Since to et al., we reasoned that the mutation of (Figure might CL We this with a side chain to the expected We first tested the ability of the resulting G4W CL to in solution using and observed that G4W formed large assemblies (Figure The at the surface of the that the 8-mer We to the effect of a at the side of the which is to form the of the We therefore tested the The MP results show that the on the other self-assembles in solution (Figure Figure with 3 supplements see all Download asset Open asset analysis that polymerization in solution is for pore (A) The of the and (green) are shown for two orientations of the 8-mer The CL sequence the of the is shown at the (B) Mass photometry shows that the G4W has a lower to form large assemblies than in solution. (C) AFM data of CL in the of membranes. The increased loop while G4W does not form scale bar = 100 nm. Representative features are from the
Source: eLife
Authors: Charles M Russell, Katherine G Schaefer, Andrew Dixson, Amber LH Gray, Robert J Pyron, Daiane S Alves, Nicholas Moore, Elizabeth A Conley, Ryan J Schuck, Tommi A White, Thanh D Do, Gavin M King, Francisco N Barrera
Institutions: University of Tennessee at Knoxville, University of Missouri
Language: English
Subfield: Infectious Diseases
Field: Medicine
Domain: Health Sciences
Open Access status: gold
Estimated APC paid: $2,500
OpenAlex ID: W4312372903
