Work

Emilio Uranga and Jorge Portilla on Accidentality as a Decolonial Tool

Year: 2023
Type: article
Abstract: Call ‘a substance’ a person who is at home in a relatively stable and unified sense-making framework: a social structure that to some degree specifies which categories are important for interpreting reality, which goals are worth pursing, which character traits are admirable, etc. Call ‘an accident’ a person who is not at home in one such framework. It is tempting to think that being a substance is preferable, but I present some considerations for thinking otherwise. Mexican philosophers Emilio Uranga and Jorge Portilla, I argue, present notions of accidentality as decolonial tools. Uranga’s account enables Mexicans to have positive valuation of their being independently of the approving gaze of the colonizers and their standards of value. Portilla’s thought distinguishes between pernicious accidentality resulting from the disintegration of sense-making frameworks and authentic accidentality as a condition for freedom, self-creation, and ultimately for individual and communal liberation.
Institution: Wingate University
Language: English
Subfield: Anthropology
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W4390420006
FWCI: 2.625
Cites: 23
Cited by: 6
Related to: 10