Work

(3031) Proposal to reject the name Bignonia hirta (Bignoniaceae)

Year: 2024
Type: article
Abstract: (3031) Bignonia hirta Vell., Fl. Flumin.: 249. 7 Sep–28 Nov 1829 [Angiosp.: Bignon.], nom. utique rej. prop. Lectotypus (hic designatus): [icon. ined.] "Didyn. Angiosp. BIGNONIA hirta Tab. 35" (Seção de Manuscritos, Bibliot. Nac., Rio de Janeiro No. I-17, 03, 002; mss1198655_039 [photo!]). Bignonia hirta Vell. (Fl. Flumin.: 249. 1829) is a name that has never been adopted since its publication. As with other names described in Florae Fluminensis, the original herbarium specimens of B. hirta were not located. The remaining original material of these names are the plates, since all taxa described in this Flora were illustrated. In the protologue of B. hirta (l.c.), Vellozo cited a plate (t. 35) that was eventually published (Vellozo, Fl. Flumin. Icones 6: t. 35. 1831). However, the published plates in Florae Fluminensis are not the author's original material, since they were published only in 1831, after the protologue (Vellozo, l.c. 1829), and were prepared long after Vellozo's death in 1811 (Blake, Diccion. Bibliogr. Brazil. 5: 64. 1899). The names and plates published in Florae Fluminensis trace to original drawings now deposited at Biblioteca Nacional do Rio de Janeiro that were available to Vellozo during the preparation of his descriptions, and these constitute the unique available choice for typification (Art. 9.3 and 9.4 of the ICN; Turland & al. in Regnum Veg. 159. 2018). These drawings and the resulting illustrations (plates) published or not published in Florae Fluminensis are the most important elements for species recognition. In a first attempt to evaluate Bignonia hirta, Bureau & Schumann (in Martius, Fl. Bras. 8(2): 221. 1896) tentatively associated the name with Stizophyllum perforatum (Cham.) Miers (in Proc. Roy. Hort. Soc. London 3: 198. 1863, based on B. perforata Cham. in Linnaea 7: 667. 1832). Disagreeing with this position, Gentry (in Taxon 24: 343. 1975) mentioned that the illustration of B. hirta in Florae Fluminensis resembles Clytostoma campanulatum (Cham.) Bureau & K. Schum. (l.c.: 148; based on B. campanulata Cham. in Linnaea 7: 711. 1833) due to the shape of the pseudostipules. However, C. campanulatum often has leaves with the terminal foliole modified as a simple tendril, as well as persistent foliaceous prophylls (Zuntini, Taxonomic Revision e Phylogeny of Bignonia L. (Bignonieae, Bignoniaceae) [Ph.D. Thesis, Univ. São Paulo]: 160. 2014), illustrated in Lohmann & al. (in Ann. Missouri Bot. Gard. 99: 373. 2014), and not drawn in the plate of B. hirta. Additionally, Gentry (l.c.) suggested that B. hirta was conspecific with Cuspidaria puberula Mart. ex DC. (Prodr. 9: 178. 1845) (= C. simplicifolia DC., Rev. Bignon.: 9. 1838). However, a resultant new combination based on Vellozo's older name was not proposed by Gentry, who commented that the illustrated reflexed anther thecae do not match the genus Cuspidaria. Because of this impasse, Gentry (l.c.: 343) concluded: "Although I cannot account for this species at present, the illustration is reasonably good and, unless based on more than one species, should eventually prove to be interpretable." More recently, Bignonia hirta has often been regarded as a heterotypic synonym of Fridericia mollis (Vahl) L.G. Lohmann & al. (1.c.: 440, based on B. mollis Vahl, Eclog. Amer. 2: 46. 1798), as by Zuntini (l.c.: 235); Kaehler (in Fl. Funga Brazil. 2024 [https://floradobrasil.jbrj.gov.br/FB113382, accessed 25 Mar 2024]); POWO (https://powo.science.kew.org/results?q=Bignonia hirta, accessed 25 Mar 2024); Tropicos (https://tropicos.org/name/100153891, accessed 25 Mar 2024). However, this taxonomic position is not supported by a comprehensive reevaluation of the identity of B. hirta. Vellozo's B. hirta plate is somewhat similar to F. mollis, but it can hardly be the same entity because F. mollis is only known from the Amazon region, and so has been collected only in the northern states of Brazil. In contrast, B. hirta presumably was originally collected in Rio de Janeiro or São Paulo (Pastore & al. in Taxon 70: 1078–1095. 2021). Furthermore, B. hirta was drawn with simple lower leaves on each branchlet, which are not present in F. mollis. In a recent review of Bignoniaceae names in Florae Fluminensis, we concluded that Bignonia hirta is very likely the same entity as Cuspidaria simplicifolia, as had already been suggested by Gentry (l.c.). This is based on consideration of diagnostic characteristics such as typically 3-foliolate leaves with pinnate venation, acute-acuminate apex and acute-cuneate base, presence of simple lower leaves on each branchlet, predominantly terminal inflorescence (though occasionally axillary), flowers adorned with indumentum in some instances and the distribution of C. simplicifolia, which occurs in Rio de Janeiro State. This conclusion would necessitate a new combination in Cuspidaria, displacing C. simplicifolia. Although the name Cuspidaria simplicifolia was published nearly two centuries ago, the species involved has been treated in distinct genera such as Arrabidaea DC. (as A. puberula (Mart. ex DC.) Bureau in Vidensk. Meddel. Naturhist. Foren. Kjøbenhavn, ser. 5, 5: 99. 1892), Setilobus Baill. (as S. simplicifolius (DC.) K. Schum. in Engler & Prantl, Nat. Pflanzenfam. 4, Abt. 3b: 221. 1894; Bureau & Schumann, l.c.: 206–207), Blepharitheca Pichon (as B. puberula (Mart. ex DC.) Pichon in Bull. Soc. Bot. France 92: 224. 1945), or Saldanhaea Bureau (as S. puberula (Mart. ex DC.) J.C. Gomes in Revista Bras. Biol. 11: 51. 1951; Sandwith in Kew Bull. 22: 406–408. 1968), or eventually retained in Cuspidaria DC. as C. puberula (Gentry, l.c.). Nevertheless, in recent years a consensus towards usage of C. simplicifolia for this taxon has emerged (e.g., Lohmann & al., 1.c.; Colombo & al. in Phytotaxa 278: 22. 2016; Villarroel & al. in Kempffiana 13: 47. 2017; Kaehler & al. in Taxon 68: 761. 2019; Costa & al. in Rodriguesia 72: 1–37. 2021; Francisco & al. in Taxon 72: 1057–1079. 2023; Francisco in Fl. Funga Brazil. 2024 [https://floradobrasil.jbrj.gov.br/FB113209, accessed 25 Mar 2024]). Still, the original plates of Florae Fluminensis are often not well detailed, leading to historical criticism regarding the overall quality of the published plates. This is also true for the Bignonia hirta plate (Vellozo, l.c. 1831: t. 35), which lacks some important features for the distinction of Cuspidaria simplicifolia, such as the anthers lacking forward curvature and the axillary inflorescence (in specimens of C. simplicifolia the inflorescence is often preceded by a leaved branchlet). Thus, a new combination would create further dispute on the application of the name, and the resulting new combination in Cuspidaria would be a disadvantageous nomenclatural change. The proposal presented here is to reject outright the name Bignonia hirta, thus preserving the use of Cuspidaria simplicifolia, a more used and now widely cited binomial in the genus Cuspidaria. This paper is part of the M.Sc. of Matheus Nascimento at the Programa de Pós-Graduação em Biologia de Fungos, Algas e Plantas of Universidade Federal de Santa Catarina. MN is thankful for the financial support from CAPES via a master's degree scholarship grant (88887.688635/2022-00). JP and JFBP thank the CNPq (Conselho Nacional de Desenvolvimento Científico e Tecnológico) for funding a research fellowship 307931/2021-8 and 304082/2023-6, respectively.
Source: Taxon
Language: Hebrew
Subfield: Plant Science
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W4399445461
FWCI: 0.359
Cites:
Cited by: 2
Related to: 10