Work

‘Ancient’ Greek History in Polybios’ Historiae: Tendencies and Political Objectives

Year: 2020
Type: article
Abstract: The modern scholarly discussion concerning Polybios' references and state ments about events, personages and exempla of the Greek History in the Archaic, Classical and early Hellenistic periods has generally been confined to the famous chapters of the "Polemic in Polybius", i.e. his critical digres sions against a whole series of prominent historians of the Greek past.1 On the other hand interest in this field has often been restricted to the literary or rather philosophical learning of Polybios -somewhat in the manner of R.v.Scala's famous work.2However, it seems useful to try a much broader approach, which can lead us to very characteristic aspects and perspectives of Polybios' work, by actually considering and scrutinizing the whole mass of allusions, remarks and comparisons relating to 'Ancient' Greek history which are preserved in Polybios' Historiae.Then we might perhaps even get some glimpses not only of Polybios' sources of information, but also of his main standpoints and orientation-marks within past and present of the Greek World.Naturally in this respect even obiter dicta could be very * This is the almost unchanged text o f a paper read at a conference on the Attitudes to the Past in Hellenistic historiography, held at the Hebrew University in Jerusalem in 14-15.11.88; bibliographical notes have been restricted to an absolute minimum. 1 Cf.esp.F. W. Walbank's famous article in JRS 52 (1962) 1-12, and ch.H "Historical Traditions" in his monograph Polybius (Berkeley 1972) 32fF., but see now Walbank's analysis: "Polybios Sicht der Vergangenheit", Gymnasium 97 (1990) 15-30; cf. also G. Α. Lehmann, "Polybios und die ältere und zeitgenössische griechische Geschicht sschreibung," in Polybe, Entretiens sur l ' Antiquité Classique, 20 (Vandoeuvres-Genève 1974) 147-205; Kl.Meister, Historische Kritik bei Polybios (Wiesbaden 1975) passim. 2
Author: G.A. Lehmann
Language: English
Subfield: Classics
Open Access status: diamond
OpenAlex ID: W4407200401
FWCI:
Cites: 1
Cited by: 30
Related to: 10