Techno-economic assessment of ear-hanging and lantern net grow-out techniques in Atlantic Sea scallop, Placopecten magellanicus, aquaculture in the Gulf of Maine
Year: 2025
Type: article
Abstract: Global scallop production has rapidly transitioned from a wild-capture fishery to an aquaculture industry over the past several decades. However, aquaculture of the Atlantic sea scallop ( Placopecten magellanicus ) in the Gulf of Maine has remained limited by the high labor burden and costs within the United States and Canada, particularly when using traditional lantern net culture. As a result, specialized ear-hanging equipment designed to automate husbandry processes is increasingly being employed in scallop aquaculture to reduce labor, despite the higher initial investment. Here, we used a techno-economic model to compare the cost of production, net present value, modified internal rate of return, lease size requirements, and labor-bounded maximum annual production of automated ear-hanging and traditional lantern net culture, production cycle duration, and market products. While ear-hanging entailed higher initial capital expenditures, it was notably more cost effective compared to lantern net culture; the advantages were compounded at larger production scales, longer production cycle durations, and when targeting an adductor muscle market. Labor efficiencies in ear-hanging related to a total annual production capacity of almost double that for lantern net culture and a lease acreage reduction of 40 % at comparable annual production. We recommend that growers looking to scale scallop production (>100,000 annual production) consider automated ear-hanging targeting an adductor muscle product. Meanwhile small-scale growers (<100,000 annual production) would likely need to adjust assumptions for a profitable business model. To assist growers in this decision-making process, we have included a scenario-testing application to adjust assumptions to fit their specific business requirements.
Source: Aquaculture
Authors: Christopher Noren, Struan Coleman, Christian Brayden, Andrew Chingos, Dana Morse, Andrew Peters, Damian C. Brady
Institutions: University of Maine, Maine Sea Grant
Language: English
Subfield: Aquatic Science
Domain: Life Sciences
Open Access status: hybrid
Estimated APC paid: $3,910
Funder: U.S. Department of Agriculture
OpenAlex ID: W4410910941
