Work

Research on University Teaching Evaluation Criteria from the Perspective of Professional Title Promotion

Year: 2025
Type: article
Abstract: Professional title promotion constitutes a critical component of faculty assessment in higher education institutions, directly influencing teachers’ value judgments and behavioral orientations. Only by granting equal respect to teaching and research within the professional title promotion system can the prevailing phenomenon of “prioritizing research over teaching” in universities be fundamentally addressed. This study analyzes policy documents on professional title promotion from seven financial and economic universities in China and one international research-oriented university. Through comparative analysis, case studies and observational insights into evaluation practices at sample universities, this research clarifies the similarities and differences in teaching evaluation criteria between domestic and international professional title promotion systems, identifies existing issues in teaching evaluation mechanisms within Chinese universities, and provides novel insights for administrators to optimize teaching evaluation criteria and advance comprehensive university teachers evaluation reforms. We found that there are problems in most universities with their teaching evaluation mechanisms, such as relatively crude teaching evaluation criteria, insufficient comprehensiveness teaching evaluation content, and the lack of peer evaluation links. Therefore, in order to better align the professional title promotion results to teachers’ teaching performance, universities should adopt a combined approach of quantitative evaluation and qualitative evaluation, highlight the differences among disciplines in the evaluation criteria, introduce teaching innovation and teaching leadership criteria, establish a shared and recognized peer evaluation mechanism for teaching performance, and strengthen the linkage and cooperation among universities.
Language: English
Subfield: Education
Open Access status: diamond
OpenAlex ID: W4412378036
FWCI: 0.58
Cites: 5
Cited by: 1
Related to: 10