Work

Comparison of methods for generating ex-ante distribution coefficients for collective self-consumption

Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: Renewable energy communities (REC) based on collective self-consumption (CSC) must allocate the generated electricity to the participant consumers. One possibility for allocation implemented in some countries consists of applying ex-ante distribution coefficients, which might be static or variable. This study assesses 16 modes for generating static and hourly-variable distribution coefficients, using different time resolutions and calculation methods: proportional to consumption (PTC) and numerical optimisation (OPT) to maximise the global self-consumption rate (SCR). The impact on energy and economic Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) is analysed in two case studies in Spain with different configurations of CSC. Case study 1 is composed by a positive energy residential building and a healthcare facility and case study 2 is formed by a school and 159 households. In both case studies, PTC and OPT modes of calculation lead to favourable outcomes for the REC compared to the individual self-consumption scenario. SCR average values for the REC are 86.4% (OPT) and 85.3% (PTC) for case study 1 and 89.2% (OPT) and 88.8% (PTC) for case study 2. OPT modes outperform PTC slightly, with average SCR of the REC for OPT lagging behind the ideal distribution – equivalent to ex-post allocation – in 2 and 3 percentage points for case study 1 and 2 respectively. Within each method, increasing temporal granularity leads to higher values of SCR for the REC. In both case studies ‘WDWE + M’ is the type of day which leads to highest SCR in all modes. However, increasing temporal granularity entails longer computation times, which reached up to 8.32 min for case study 1 in OPT modes. The improvement obtained with 24 coefficients per day over a constant value for case study 1 is insufficient to offset the increased computational resource. REC economic savings also increased in both case studies in comparison to the base scenario of individual self-consumption, with an increase of 14% and 127% for case study 1 and 2, respectively. Nonetheless this KPI is less affected by the calculation mode chosen and depends on tariff type and consumption patterns. Asymmetries between individual users’ results are identified and a compensation for the allocated energy is proposed, which still allows for positive results for the REC. These results provide insights into the most effective criteria for maximising the impact of CSC, raising concern about fair allocation criteria.
Language: English
Open Access status: hybrid
Estimated APC paid: $4,260
OpenAlex ID: W4415596331
FWCI: 2.634
Cites: 17
Cited by: 2
Related to: 9