Work

Judicial Mediation and Signaling

Year: 2003
Type: conference-paper
Abstract: Two seemingly inconsistent developments in settling pending litigation merit special attention.Pretrial conferences conducted under Rule 16 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure afford the trial judge an opportunity to engage in a range of settlement activities.The court may "signal" the likely result with a not too subtle query, may ask the parties to attend a settlement conference, or may set an impossible trial date that leaves little alternative but to settle.Under this "traditional" view, the judge will strive to settle cases assigned to the trial court.Put succinctly, the all-purpose judges who use this traditional view unabashedly try to settle their own cases, and later preside over the trial if settlement is not reached.'A judge's settlement effort may take alternative forms, ranging from a formal judicial mediation to an evaluative pretrial comment that a party's case "looks weak."However, the modem view proceeds in a markedly different direction.Increasingly, judges are using the pretrial process to set settlement conferences before a different judge of the same court.Judge A will use a pretrial conference to ask or cajole the parties into agreeing to participate in a settlement conference held before Judge B. Judge B will often be a self-appointed specialist at settling cases and may be trained in mediation techniques.Many courthouses have one or more judges who are very skilled mediators and would prefer to mediate rather than try cases.When the parties appear before Judge B for their settlement conference, the court will essentially be mediating the case.This is modem judicial mediation, characterized by a clear division of labor between the judge assigned to a case and the judge who mediates.This article will analyze the tension that exists between the traditional view, under which courts seek to settle and evaluate their own cases, and the modem view, under which the case is assigned to a different, more "neutral" judge who may be an expert in settling cases using mediation techniques.The term "judicial mediation" as used in this essay includes, but goes beyond, mere settlement conferences or judicial mediation sessions.It broadly embraces the concept of settlement efforts by a trial judge and includes any oral or written case evaluation whatsoever by a judge.Here, the term includes signaling by the assigned trial judge at a Rule 16 pre-trial conference (e.g., comments by the court that a particular claim or defense may "appear unsubstantiated"), similar evaluative comments made by the trial court when
Language: English
Subfield: Law
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W54201485
FWCI:
Cites:
Cited by: 14
Related to: 10