Work

The foundations of personality.

Year: 1921
Type: book
Abstract: PERSONALITYor phrenology, and the study of the hand or palmistry.All of these systems are really " materialistic " in that they postulate so close a union of mind and body as to make them inseparable.But there are grave difficulties in the way of character-judging by these methods.Take, for example, the study of the physiognomy as a means to character un- derstanding.All the physiognomists, as well as the average man, look upon the high, wide brow as related to great intelligence.And so it issometimes.But it is also found in connection with disease of the brain, as in hydrocephalus, and in old cases of rickets.You may step into hospitals for the feeble-minded or for the insane and find here and there a high, noble brow.Conversely you may attend a scientific convention and find that the finest paper of the meeting will be read not by some Olympian-browed member, but by a man with a low, receding forehead, who nevertheless possesses a high-grade intellect.So for centuries men have recognized in the large aquiline nose a sign of power and ability.Napoleon's famous dictum that no man with this type of proboscis is a fool has been accepted by many, most of whom, like Napoleon probably, have large aquiline noses.The number of failures with this facial peculiarity has never been studied, nor has any one remarked that many a highly successful man has a snub nose.And in fact the only kind of a nose that has a real character value is the one presenting no obstruction to breathing.The assigned value given to a " pretty " nose has no relation to character, except as its owner is vain because of it.One might go on indefinitely discussing the various features of the face and discovering that only a vague relationship to character existed.The thick, moist has in my experience more often been the result of rickets than a sign of parental love.Without meaning to pun, we may dismiss the claims of palmistry offhand.Normally the lines of the hand do not change from birth to deatH, but character does change.The hand, its shape and its texture are mark- edly influenced by illness,^toil and care.And gait, car- riage, clothes and the dozen and one details by which we judge our fellows indicate health, strength, training and culture, all of which are components of character, or rather are characters of importance but give no clue to the deeper-lying traits.As a matter of fact, judgment of character will never be attained through the study of face, form or hand.As language is a means not only of expressing truth but of disguising it, so these surface phenomena are as often masks as guides.Any sober-minded student of life, intent on knowing himself or his fellows, will seek no royal road to this knowledge, but will endeavor to understand the fundamental forces of character, will *Xotably is the shape of the hand changed by chronic heart and lung disease and by arthritis.But the influence of the endocrinal se- cretions ia very great.* Hocking. THE FOUNDATIONS OF PERSONALITYof the imprint of medicine, of neurology, than of psy- chology and philosophy.Yet it has also laid under contribution these fields of human effort.Mainly it will, I hope, bear the marks of everyday experience, of contact with the world and with men and women and children as brother, husband, father, son, lover, hater, citizen, doer and observer.For it is this plurality of contact that vitalizes, and he who has not drawn his universals of character out of the particulars of everyday life is a cloistered theorist, aloof from reality.CHAPTER I THE ORGANIC BASIS OF CHARACTERThe history of Man's thought is the real history of mankind.Back of all the events of history are the curious systems of beliefs for which men have lived and died.Struggling to understand himself, Man has built up and discarded superstitions, theologies and sciences.Early in this strange and fascinating history he divided himself into two parts-a body and a mind.Working together with body, mind somehow was of different stuff and origin than body and had only a mysterious connection with it.Theology supported this belief ; metaphysics and philosophy debated it with an acumen that was practically sterile of usefulness.Mind and body " interacted " in some mysterious way ; mind and body were " parallel " and so set that thought- processes and brain-processes ran side by side without really having anything to do with one another.^Withthe development of modern anatomy, physiology and psychology, the time is ripe for men boldly to say that applying the principle of causation in a practical man-* William James in Volume 1 of his " Psychology " gives an inter- esting r^sum^of the theories that consider the relationship of mind (thought and consciousness) to body.He quotes the "lucky" paragraph from Tyndall, ** The passage from the physics of the brain to the corresponding facts of consciousness is unthinkable.Granted that a definite thought and a definite molecular action in the brain occur simultaneously; we do not possess the intellectual organ, or apparently any trace of the organ which would enable us to pass by a process of reasoning from one to the other."This is the " parallel " theory ' What is called coarse is frequently crudely true.Thus, in the streets, in the workshops, and where men untrammeled by niceties engage in personalities, the one who believes the other to be a " crank " informs him in crude language that he has intestinal stasis (to put the diagnosis in medical language) and advises him accordingly to "take a pill."THE ORGANIC BASIS OF CHARACTER 19 A child shows the onset of an illness by a complete , change in character.I remember one sociable, amiable lad of two, rich in the curiosity and expanding friend- liness of that time of life, who became sick with diph- theria.All his basic moods became altered, and all his wholesome reactions to life disappeared.He was cross and contrary, he had no interest in people or in things, he acted very much as do those patients in an insane hospital who suffer from Dementia Praecox.What is character if it is not interest and curiosity, v'' friendliness and love, obedience and trust, cheerfulness and courage?Yet a sick child, especially if very young, loses all these and takes on the reverse characters.The little lad spoken of became " himself " again when the * For example, read what the hard-headed Galton says ("Hereditary Genius," p. 376):" There is decidedly a solidarity as well as a separateness in all human and probably in all lives whatsoever, and this consideration goes far, I think, to establish an opinion that the constitution of the living universe is a pure theism and that its form of activity is what may be described as cooperative.It points to the conclusion that all life is single in its essence, but various, ever-varying and interactive in its manifestations, and that men and all other living animals are active workers and sharers in a vastly more extended system of cosmic action than any of ourselves, much less of them, can possibly compre- hend.It also suggests that they may contribute, more or less unconsciously, to the manifestation of a far higher life than our ovm, somewhat as ... the individual cells of one of the more complex animals contribute to the manifestations of its higher order of per- sonality."* Nietzsche.30 THE FOUNDATIONS OF PERSONALITY world were animate, like himself, and that they might be moved, persuaded, cajoled and frightened into favor- able action, undeveloped man based most of his customs on efforts to obtain some desired result from the gods.Out of these customs grew the majority of our institu- tions; out of these queer beliefs and superstitions, out of witchcraft, sympathetic magic, the " Old Man " idea, the primitive reaction to sleep, epilepsy and death grew medicine, science, religion, festivals, the kingship, the idea of soul and most of the other governing and direct- ing ideas of our lives.It is true that the noble beliefs and sciences also grew from these rude seeds, but with them and permeating our social structure are crops of atrophied ideas, hampering customs, cramping ideals.Further, in every race in every counti*y, in every family, there are somewhat different assortments of these di- recting traditional forces ; and it is these social inheritances which are more responsible for difference in people than a native difference in stock.Consider the difference that being born and brought up in Turkey and being born, let us say, in New York City, would make in two children of exactly the same disposition, mental caliber and physical structure.One would grow up a Turk and the other a New Yorker, and the mere fact that they had the same original capacity for thought, feeling and action would not alter the result that in character the two men would stand almost at opposite poles.One need not judge between them and say that one was superior to the other, for while I feel that the New Yorker might stand our inspection better, I am certain that the Turk would be more pleas- ing to Turkish ideas.The point is that they would be different and that the differences would result solely ENVIRONMENTAL BASIS OF CHARACTER 31 from the environmental forces of natural conditions and social inheritance.Study the immigrant to the United States and his descendant, American born and bred.Compare Irish- man and Irish-American, Russian Jew and his Ameri- can-born descendant; compare Englishman and the Anglo-Saxon New England descendant.Here is a race, the Jew, which in the Ghetto and under circumstances that built up a tremendously powerful set of traditions and customs developed a very distinctive type of human being.Poor in physique, with little physical pugnacity, but worshiping, learning and reaching out for wealth and power in an unusually successful manner, the cru- cible of an adverse and hostile environment rendered him totally different in manners from his Gentile neigh- bors.With a high birth rate and an intensely close and pure family life, the Ghetto Jew lived and died shut off by the restrictions placed upon him and his own social heredity from the life of the country of his birth.
Language: English
Field: Psychology
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W601227315
FWCI: 38.5
Cites:
Cited by: 29
Related to: 9