Mediating the Evaluative-Facilitative Debate: Why Both Parties Are Wrong and a Proposal for Settlement
Year: 2007
Type: article
Abstract: In 1994 and 1996, Leonard Riskin published two articles analyzing the “facilitative” and “evaluative” methods of mediation. The articles generated a great deal of debate over the two styles of mediation. Some contend that evaluative methods violate the principles of mediation and undermine its goal of assisting the parties to come to their own conclusions. Others contend that there is no such thing as purely facilitative mediation and that all mediation requires evaluative methods. This article respectfully submits that many practitioners have not focused on this distinction during actual complex commercial mediation, simply because evaluative methods are inseparable from facilitative methods. In the real world of complex commercial mediation, evaluative methods together with facilitative methods have proven essential and indispensable for achieving success. Success in mediation is not characterized by a settlement between the parties. Instead, a successful mediation is one that provides decision makers with information they can use to reevaluate their positions, make informed business decisions, and engage in a systematic modification of their initial positions, or an “organized retreat.” Further, a successful mediation provides decision makers with new information, a better understanding of the case, or a clearer grasp of their chances of prevailing or losing at the next level. Even when mediation does not result in settlement, lawyers and clients who engage in evaluative mediation often find the mediation process beneficial. Unlike facilitative mediation, evaluative mediation results in the mediator providing information to the parties, which is key to a successful mediation. Thus, evaluative and facilitative methods are interdependent in successful complex commercial mediation, and “the
Author: Kenneth M. Roberts
Language: English
Subfield: Law
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W6132311
