Proposal and Analysis of a Unitary System for Review of Criminal Judgments
Year: 1974
Type: article
Abstract: Debate continues over expanded use of habeus corpus for collateral attack of criminal judgments. Some commentators argue that the current system of seemingly endless post-conviction review fails to provide the finality and integrity required of any truly fair and effective system of criminal justice. Others claim that such an expansive post-conviction remedy system is justified when a man's liberty is at stake. It is a central thesis of this article that not only does the present system of post-conviction remedies fall short of achieving adequate fairness and comprehensiveness, but also that the attempt to achieve these values has produced a fragmented, ineffective system of review tangled in unjustified technical rules and unnecessary procedures. It will be argued that this unnecessary confusion has been caused by an indefensible reliance upon the historical distinction between direct and collateral attack. As long as both groups continue to adamantly strive only for the ultimate victory of their own point of view, it is unlikely that a truly adequate and equitable review system will ever be achieved. It may be possible, however, to defuse the current debate while at the same time promoting the primary values advocated by both sides. The system of review proposed here offers an acceptable compromise between the apparently irreconcilable positions.
Author: Paul H. Robinson
Institution: University of Pennsylvania
Language: English
Topic: Criminal Law and Evidence
Subfield: Law
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W620647499
