Work

Second-guessing Guessing : Questioning the Top-down Reading Strategy of Guessing Word Meaning from Context

Year: 1997
Type: article
Abstract: In 1967, Kenneth Goodman published a paper on reading that included his now famous view of reading as a psycholinguistic guessing game. He went on in later years to refine a model of reading reflecting this perspective(see Goodman,1967; 1973;1975(in Carrell, et al,1988). The dominant view prior to this was of reading as a linear process starting with the written symbol and then moving on through stages of phonemic, syntactic, and semantic stages of processing that led to comprehen・ sion. This is commonly known as bottom-up processing, which involves data-driven, part-to-whole processing, as opposed to a conceptually driven, whole-to-part top-down process(Carrell,1988;Eskey,1988;Nation and Coady, 1988).Goodman s model proposes that readers rely mostly on high-level knowledge of existing syntactic and semantic structures and much less on graphic information and symbo1-to-sound-to-meaning. The model, while recognizing the interaction of both bottom-up and top-down processes, emphasizes that reading is basically concept driven(Grabe,1988). Frank Smith(1982)expanded upon Goodman s original work and produced a complementary model of reading. The work of the two is similar and influential enough that the model of reading as a psycholinguistic guessing game is often referred to as the Goodman-Smith model(Underwood and Batt,1996). Coady s (1979)model of the ESL reader(as opposed to the LI reader, which is the focus of the Goodman model)has also been innuential. It, too, leans more towards the importance of higher level processing and ties in with the general orientation of the Goodman-Smith model as well(Barnett,1989). The psycholinguistic approach to reading has benefited from the influence of schema theory on language learning pedagogy. Schema theory is the result of the convergence of research interests in linguistics, psychology, and artificial intelligence・In brief, it proposes that higher-level knowledge structures affect and/or guide the reading and comprehension processes(Anderson and Pearson,1984;Carrell and Eisterhold, 1987;Seffensen and Joag-Dev,1984). Research findings and speculation based upon them lend support to the psycholinguistic approach and its emphasis on the function
Author: David Dycus
Language: English
Field: Psychology
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W654040992
FWCI:
Cites: 9
Cited by: 12
Related to: 9