Dimensional perspective in ADHD neurodevelopment as a foundation for translational interventions: The role of executive and arousal attentional processes
Year: 2023
Type: dissertation
Study design: Observational Study
Abstract: Attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) is commonly conceptualized as a \nneurodevelopmental condition characterized by age-inappropriate and impairing levels of \ninattention and/or hyperactivity–impulsivity. After decades of prolific basic research into \nthe causes and mechanisms underlying the disorder, these findings have failed to \ntranslate into interventions with a substantial impact on core ADHD symptoms. To move \npast this situation, a shift from the medical to the biopsychosocial model of the disorder is \ncrucial. Based on empirical evidence, the biopsychosocial model adopts a dimensional \nperspective of ADHD as well as other more complex yet less restrictive assumptions than \nthe medical one, holding considerable hope for translational progress. \nAs part of the dimensional perspective, a fundamental step is the integration \nbetween theories aimed at explaining the general neurocognitive functioning and those \nthat account for its variation as a function of ADHD symptom severity. Indeed, the potential \nalterations in ADHD should be nested within well-established neurocognitive models. In \nthis dissertation, we focused on attention—understood as a general modulatory system of \ncognition—as a central axis for characterizing two key and dissociable mechanisms in \nboth typical cognitive functioning and ADHD theories: executive and arousal processes. \nEach of these two domains constitutes an independent mechanism in models of the \ngeneral functioning of attentional networks (M. I. Posner & Petersen, 1990) and vigilance \n(Luna et al., 2018). Furthermore, the main theories of ADHD are distinguished between \nthose based on executive dysfunction (Barkley, 1997) and those focused on arousal \ndysregulation (Sergeant, 2000, 2005). Crucial for the recent debate on the nature of lateonset \nADHD, Halperin and Schulz’s (2006) neurodevelopmental model proposes a \ndissociation between arousal and executive mechanisms when accounting for the early \nonset of ADHD versus its later development. \nBased on this dimensional perspective of ADHD within the broader biopsychosocial \nframework, the aim of the present dissertation was to deepen our understanding of the \nexecutive and arousal attentional alterations underlying ADHD symptoms across \ndevelopment, ultimately considering implications for translational interventions. The \nachievement of this general objective was carried out in five studies grouped into three \nchapters plus an overarching conceptual analysis that discusses the translational \ncontributions of our findings. \nFirst, we sought to establish a neurocognitive behavioural task capable of (a) \nfeasibly collecting large samples from different contexts, (b) measuring relevant indices of \nattentional functioning with sufficient reliability, and (c) differentiating between executive \nand arousal measures. To do so, we conducted an instrumental study focused on the \nAttentional Networks Test for Interaction and Vigilance—Executive and Arousal \nComponents (ANTI-Vea; Luna et al., 2018). Based on the theoretical models of attention \nmentioned above, this task assesses the functioning of the three attentional networks \n(alerting, orienting, and executive control) and two vigilance components (executive and \narousal). In this study, we developed a free and online resource to easily run, collect, and \nanalyze large volumes of data from the ANTI-Vea, both in typical lab conditions and online \nin remote settings: the ANTI-Vea-UGR platform. Consistent with open science principles, \nthe task versions are open source, anonymized ANTI-Vea online participant data is stored \non a freely accessible public server, and task analyses can be performed using a custom \nShiny app or with its associated R code. In addition, we undertook a narrative review of \nthe more than a dozen studies, encompassing over a thousand participants in total, that \nhave employed ANTI-Vea. We concluded that the reliability of most ANTI-Vea indices was \nacceptable when the task was used in large samples. Crucially, executive and arousal \nprocesses were empirically dissociated using the ANTI-Vea, both through experimental \nmanipulations and within the association pattern of some attention-related constructs. \nSecond, we conducted an empirical series of three associative studies, all following \na very similar procedure: A community sample of university students perform the ANTIVea \nand complete self-reports on the severity of their ADHD symptoms in childhood \n(retrospectively assessed) and adulthood. The first of these studies (N = 113), of a more \nexploratory nature, found a neurodevelopmental dissociation consistent with Halperin and \nSchulz’s (2006) neurodevelopmental model. Concretely, arousal indices (i.e., alerting \nnetwork and arousal vigilance) correlated with ADHD symptoms in childhood, whereas \nthe decrement in executive vigilance was linked to higher symptoms in adulthood. The \nsecond study (N = 292) was a preregistered close replication of the previous one with a \ngreater focus on transparently testing the hypothesized neurodevelopmental dissociation \nbetween executive and arousal vigilance in relation to ADHD symptoms. Unexpectedly, \nneither preregistered nor multiverse analyses supported the predictions of the \nneurodevelopmental model. The third study (N = 492) combined the samples from the two \nprevious studies with a third sample in which participants performed the ANTI-Vea task \nmultiple times to shed light on the neurocognitive characterization of late-onset ADHD. \nThis final pattern of results did not support a neurodevelopmental dissociation either. On \nthe contrary, both executive and arousal alterations were associated with ADHD \nsymptoms in childhood, adulthood, and late onset (i.e., symptoms in adulthood after \ncontrolling for those in childhood). \nThird, we presented the protocol of a systematic review and meta-analysis of the \neffects of nonpharmacological interventions for ADHD on indices of autonomic arousal. \nArousal dysregulation in ADHD, often in the form of hypo-arousal, is a potential target and \nmediator in interventions aimed at improving ADHD symptoms. Arousal measures of the \nautonomic nervous system include cardiac, electrodermal, and pupil activity, among \nothers. The twofold aim of this study was (a) to examine whether current \nnonpharmacological interventions for ADHD, translational or not, can enhance the regulation of arousal mechanisms; and (b) to identify promising arousal-based \ntranslational interventions for ADHD. Preliminary results have identified 12 studies. \nHowever, due to the low statistical power and high heterogeneity across study designs \nand intervention types, drawing robust conclusions on the current state of the art in this \narea was challenging. \nFinally, we attempted to integrate our findings with the previous literature to derive \nproposals that may contribute to the future of translational interventions for ADHD in two \nkey issues: \n1. Neurocognitive nature of late-onset ADHD. Evidence mostly suggests that lateonset \nADHD is not distinct from conventional ADHD at the neurocognitive level. \nThis implies that translational interventions for ADHD should target the same \nunderlying alterations across different stages of development, regardless of the \nage of disorder onset. Furthermore, this supports the idea that both child- and \nadult-onset ADHD can be conceptualized as mere variants of the same disorder. \nWhether this single disorder is neurodevelopmental or not is an open question that \ndepends on the role (moderating vs. causal) of late-onset ADHD precursors. \n2. Mechanisms of translational interventions. As we have shown, both executive and \narousal alterations may underlie ADHD symptoms. However, interventions for \nADHD have typically been designed to train executive domains (e.g., computerbased \ncognitive training), while targeting arousal regulation is generally neglected. \nThis contrasts to current models of cognitive training, which propose that the \ntransfer of gains is largely due to mechanisms of cognitive efficiency, which are not \nprimarily executive. Therefore, arousal-based translational interventions for ADHD, \nsuch as effort training through learned industriousness or trigeminal nerve \nstimulation, are postulated as promising therapeutic options. \nOverall, although the therapeutic progress derived from ADHD basic research is \nlimited, we believe that the translational logic of targeting neurocognitive processes \nthought to mediate ADHD pathophysiology to improve core symptoms and related \nimpairment still has viability. While the contributions of this thesis are tentative and \nsomewhat constrained by the design of studies, our adoption of the \nbiopsychosocial/dimensional model and the open science framework is, in our view, \nessential to building a more sound and translatable ADHD science. Beyond translational \ninterventions, promoting inclusive environments of acceptance and appreciation towards \nthe diverse ways of thinking and behaving of people with ADHD is fundamental to the \ndevelopment of their personal growth, strengths, and empowerment in our society.
Author: Coll Martín, Tao
Institution: Universidad de Granada
Language: English
Subfield: Psychiatry and Mental health
Field: Medicine
Domain: Health Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7065254646
