Work

What multi-disciplinary delivery models for Occupational Health services are effective for whom? An umbrella review

Year: 2022
Type: article
Study design: Systematic Review
Abstract: This report should be cited as: X we focused on the 24 where the population and intervention characteristics within the systematic reviews were the most relevant to our research questions.The 24 reviews were of varying quality, split evenly between High/Moderate quality and Low/Critically Low-quality ratings.We mapped these 24 reviews in an evidence and gap map (https://eppi.ioe.ac.uk/cms/Portals/35/Maps/MN_Exeter_Feb22.html),providing a visual representation of the evidence.Due to the heterogeneity of the interventions included within the systematic reviews, we were unable to structure the map according to the different types of intervention being evaluated.Instead, using the evidence and gap map, it is possible to view i) the quality and quantity of systematic review evidence for a given health condition, ii) how the review authors rated the effectiveness or cost-effectiveness of the interventions included.Furthermore, by navigating the evidence and gap map, one can see the relevant primary studies within each review.Our umbrella review provides the first point of reference for interventions under the broad remit of multidisciplinary OH services involving the workplace, across any health condition leading to sick leave.However, the body of systematic review evidence about multidisciplinary models of OH services is highly heterogeneous in terms of intervention, health condition, size and quality and we were unable to draw conclusions about the relative effectiveness of different interventions across health conditions from this body of evidence. What are the implications?This umbrella review has highlighted an array of systematic review evidence that exists in relation to the effectiveness or cost-effectiveness of multi-disciplinary OH interventions in supporting RTW.This evidence may be useful for supporting policy makers and commissioners of services to determine which OH interventions may be most useful for supporting different population groups in different contexts.OH professionals may find the content of the evidence and gap map useful in identifying systematic review evidence to support their practice.The evidence and gap map also identifies where systematic review evidence in this area is lacking, or where existing evidence is of poor quality.These may represent areas where it may be particularly useful to conduct further systematic reviews.This umbrella review also highlights the primary studies within these reviews which are specifically relevant to our research aims and objectives.A series of smaller, more specific, systematic reviews, including a search focused on identifying primary studies, quality appraisal and full synthesis, could be conducted using these studies as a starting point/basis to determine the confidence which can be placed in the descriptive findings of this review.How did we get these results?We followed best practice guidance, and our protocol was registered on the Open Science Framework.Our approach was that of an umbrella review, featuring a rigorous search for systematic review evidence, critical appraisal and mapping of evidence. Finding the systematic review evidenceThe search strategy included search terms that describe returning to work, such as 'return to work', 're-entering work' and 'vocational rehabilitation', in conjunction with a systematic review study type filter.An historical date limit of 2001 was applied, and the results limited to English language studies.We searched a selection of health and non-health care bibliographic databases and search engines to identify evidence from a variety of sectors of employment.To identify grey literature we searched Google Search, Google Scholar and a selection of topically relevant websites.We also consulted with stakeholders to identify reports already known to them.We sought systematic reviews about adults (16 or over) in employment who have had absence or are absent from work for any medical reason and were receiving an intervention to get them back to work or help them retain work.Interventions needed to be multi-disciplinary (including professionals from different backgrounds in clinical and non-clinical professions) and designed to support employees and employers to manage health conditions in the workplace and/or to help employees with health conditions retain work and/or return to work following medical absence.Effectiveness needed to be measured in terms of return to work, work retention or measures of absence, or economic evaluation outcomes. Data extraction and quality appraisalSummary data for each eligible review was extracted.More detailed data extraction was carried out for the twenty-four reviews rated as being the most relevant to the aims of our umbrella review.Then, details of the primary studies identified within these reviews that met our inclusion criteria, were extracted.This aimed to supplement data which was reported poorly at the level of the review and focused on information about the professionals who delivered the intervention.All data were extracted by one reviewer and checked by a second, with disagreements being settled through discussion.The quality of the systematic reviews rated as high or medium relevance following full-text screening was appraised using the AMSTAR-2 quality appraisal tool. Data analysis and presentationSummary data for all eligible systematic reviews were tabulated and described narratively.The data extracted from reviews of High and Medium relevance was imported into EPPI-Mapper software to create an evidence and gap map (https://eppi.ioe.ac.uk/cms/Portals/35/Maps/MN_Exeter_Feb22.html)The evidence and gap map was structured according to the health condition that led to sick leave, and the main findings relating to the return to work outcome(s) reported at review level.The size and colour of the circles within each segment of the map represent the number and quality of reviews reporting RTW outcomes for interventions conducted with particular health conditions.Each segment can be clicked upon to view the abstracts of the systematic reviews included in that segment, and a link to the included primary studies which were relevant to our umbrella review.Details of the systematic reviews included within the map were tabulated and described narratively.Primary studies which were relevant to the aims of our umbrella review were tagged in the record of the included systematic review within the map. Stakeholder involvementWe worked alongside a variety of stakeholders and advisors to ensure our umbrella review reflects the needs of individuals who will use it.Stakeholders included commissioners and policy makers from DHSC and DWP, OH personnel and people with lived experience of accessing OH services themselves and/or supporting employees to access OH services.Was the intervention delivered by an MDT? Comparator N/A Outcome Was a RTW outcome measured Other Did the review conduct an adequate synthesis of primary studies?MDT=Multidisciplinary Team, N/A=Not applicable, RTW=Return to Work During the study selection process, we were over-inclusive, including all systematic reviews that appeared to meet the eligibility criteria but tagged each review with the uncertainties encountered in applying the criteria. Data extractionWe conducted data extraction in three stages.In the first stage, summary data for each eligible review was extracted by one reviewer and checked by a second using Microsoft Excel (LS, SGS, HL, MN).The summary data extracted from each included review is detailed in Appendix C: Summary data extracted from all eligible reviews
Authors: E Shaw, M Nunns, S Spicer, H Lawal, S Briscoe, GJ Melendez-Torres, R Garside, K Liabo, J Thompson Coon
Language: English
Field: Medicine
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7072032096
FWCI: 0.508
Cites: 343
Cited by: 3
Related to: 10