Year: 2023
Type: dissertation
Abstract: The purpose of this study is to provide critical analysis on Jamil Zaki's perspective on empathy, giving implications on moral education. Past studies of empathy in moral education have focused on fixism, which defines emotion and empathy as unchangeable traits. On the other hand, Zaki refers to emotion and empathy as malleable traits, meaning there is a possibility of improving students' ability to empathize with others. However, there have been few studies related to malleability of empathy. In addition, most studies on the Moral/Ethics curriculum are based on the definition of empathy from Martin Hoffman, which is limited to empathic distress. However, according to Zaki's perspective, it is critical to think inclusively about empathy in terms of three elements: experience sharing, mentalizing, and empathic concern. Thus, studies criticizing the 2015 revised Moral/Ethics curriculum in the lens of Zaki are in need. \n\tHis argument consists of three concepts on empathy. First, he mentions the malleability of human nature, explaining human nature is continuously changing. Second, he defines empathy as an umbrella term to cover three elements: experience sharing, mentalizing, and empathic concern. Lastly, he argues that empathy is a result of making decisions based on psychological tuning. Thus, based on three concepts of empathy, people can choose empathy through conscious interventions. For example, two kinds of intervention can be followed: one is fast-twitch change, which is unlikely to endure, such as nudge and contact, and the other is slow-twitch change, which is durable, such as meditation, mindset and social norms. \n\tTwo aspects need to be discussed to adopt Jamil Zaki's argument to moral education, when it is adopted to moral education. First, his concept of empathy is suitable for moral education because it satisfies the two necessities: morality, referringan ability to solve problems considering socio-cultural needs. and malleability, meaning the ability to be easily changed with a wide range. \n\tNext, the concept of empathic accuracy needs to be extended into 1) the accuracy of experience sharing 2) the accuracy of mentalizing and 3) the accuracy of empathic concerns. This is because Jamil Zaki's understanding of empathic accuracy is limited to only one aspect, that is, mentalizing. However, based on the theory of constructed emotion, emotions are social reality. People construct their instances of emotion as a conceptual system within specific social contexts. \n\tJamil Zaki's argument provides three implications. First, the moral educational curriculum should embrace the mobilist view of empathy. The guidelines in the 2015 revised Moral/Ethics curriculum underestimate the malleability of human nature. Second, in terms of teaching and learning methods, it is important to develop question strategies to improve empathic accuracy. Finally, instructional models of utilizing social norms need to be developed to build empathy for young learners.
Author: 엄국영
Institution: Seoul National University
Language: Korean
Topic: Values and Moral Education
Subfield: Education
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
SDG: Quality education
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7072829365
