Running Shoe Recommendations Based on Gait Analysis Improve Perceptions of Comfort, Performance and Injury Risk: A Single‐Blind Randomised Crossover Trial
Year: 2025
Type: article
Study designs: Randomized Controlled Trial, Clinical Trial
Abstract: Objectives We examined how shoe recommendation based on gait analysis influences subjective perceptions of comfort, performance and injury reduction in runners while monitoring spatiotemporal and kinematic parameters. Design Single‐blind crossover randomised controlled trial with repeated measures. Method Twenty‐one women runners completed a clinical gait analysis and four 5‐min treadmill trials at a self‐selected comfortable speed sequentially in their own shoes (OS), the first experimental shoes (randomised), their OS, and the second experimental shoes (randomised). The two experimental shoes were identical except for their colour (randomised) and were presented to runners as either a ‘basic’ shoe or, deceptively, a ‘gait‐matched’ shoe selected for them based on the clinical gait analysis conducted. Results Running Comfort Assessment Tool (RUN‐CAT) scores and 100 mm visual analogue scale ratings of subjective comfort, performance and injury reduction differed significantly between own and experimental shoes ( p < 0.001). Post‐hoc comparisons revealed that runners’ OS were the most comfortable (83.3 ± 3.8 mm) followed by gait‐matched (66.1 ± 21.5 mm) and then basic (49.0 ± 24.1 mm) shoes. RUN‐CAT, performance and injury reduction ratings were similar between own and gait‐matched shoes, but gait‐matched shoes had better mean difference (95% confidence intervals), RUN‐CAT (15.6 mm [5.7, 25.5]), performance (17.1 mm [5.6, 28.6]) and injury reduction (30.1 mm [8.9, 51.2]) scores than the basic shoes. Discrete spatiotemporal, foot strike angle and resultant tibial acceleration parameters were not significantly different between shoes ( p ≥ 0.157). Most runners overall preferred their OS (71.4%), followed by gait‐matched (23.8%) and basic (4.8%) shoes. Conclusions Shoe recommendation and description can significantly affect subjective shoe comfort and overall preferences without significantly altering spatiotemporal and kinematic parameters. Runners should be cautious while choosing shoes based on recommendations and descriptors derived from gait analysis or based solely on perceived comfort as runners’ subjective perceptions can be artificially manipulated. Trial Registration: Australian New Zealand Clinical Trials Registry: ACTRN12623000516684.
Source: Translational Sports Medicine
DOI: 10.1155/tsm2/1419641
Language: English
Subfield: Biomedical Engineering
Field: Engineering
Domain: Physical Sciences
Open Access status: gold
Estimated APC paid: $840
Funder: University of Waikato
OpenAlex ID: W7111237657
