O tratamento dos conhecimentos linguístico-gramaticais em concursos públicos (2010-2019)
Year: 2024
Type: dissertation
Abstract: This thesis investigates the linguistic-grammatical knowledge in tests of public tenders held at national level, in the interstice of a decade. From a theoretical-methodological point of view, the research is primarily located in Applied Linguistics, in its transdisciplinary and applied social perspective (Cavalcanti, 1986; Moita Lopes, 1996, 2006, 2013; Celani, 1998), and, secondarily, in the fields of Linguistic Policy (Cooper, 1989; Schiffman, 2006; Spolsky, 2009; Shohamy, 2006, 2009) and Historiography of Linguistics (Koerner, 1996; Swiggers, 1990, 2013). We start from the perception of a different scenario for treatmenting of linguistic grammatical knowledge in public exams vs. teaching context, from which we raise elements to defend the thesis that public exams have not fulfilled their purpose as an isonomic and democratic instrument in selecting candidates for public office. The research is guided by a linguistic bias, in which categories' levels of language analysis and approach are observed; and by a sociopolitical bias, in which the public tender is evaluated as an effectively democratic instrument in the selection of candidates. For the analysis, 118 study programs presented in the calls for tenders and 1962 objective questions contained in written tests of higher and middle level competitions, for various positions, of tenders held in the period from 2010 to 2019 were selected. In order to answer the research questions linked to the linguistic front, (i) we mapped the quantitative distribution of the contents, considering the levels of linguistic-grammatical analysis (phonetic-phonological, morphosyntactic, semantic and textual) and the approaches (traditional and sociodiscursive) observed in the study programs and in the objective questions; (ii) we established relationships of continuities and discontinuities, convergences and divergences, between the categories of analysis; and (iii) we observed the crossing of the different research traditions in the study programs and in the objective questions. In order to answer the questions related to the socio-political front, (iv) we sought to understand the current configuration of public tenders from the survey of elements of an external nature to the contests and (v) we have discussed the (non-) attendance of the public tender as an effectively democratic and isonomic instrument. The results of the linguistic front attest to (i) the preference in the exploration of language's morphosyntactic level and (ii) predominance of the traditional approach in portuguese language tests of public competitions of higher and secondary education levels. These findings confirm the productivity of language exploration in the morphosyntactic dimension and normative tendency that leads to valorization of an idealized grammatical pattern. Analysis regarding the socio-political front reveals the public tender as a not so democratic tool in selecting candidates, due, notably, to its constitution as a social mechanism of linguistic policy – by fostering beliefs about language, projecting excessively normative linguistic ideologies, delegitimizing linguistic varieties of brazilian portuguese and electing a social profile to occupy public positions. With these findings, we ratify the thesis defended and point out the need to (i) develop a collective consciousness about normativity; (ii) discuss the power relations and social implications of the standard norm domain; (iii) think of a portuguese language teaching that contemplates the proposed objectives for language teaching (the heterogeneity of the language, the grammatical systematics, the interactivity that constitutes and models linguistic uses), as attention to the norm domain used in social situations; and (iv) think of language treatment strategies in public competitions that are fairer and more consistent with the duties of the positions.
Language: Portuguese
Subfield: Education
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7119258005
