Teaching of the writing: a critical analysis of the imposition of a cultural arbitrary turned into a supposed consensus
Year: 2022
Type: dissertation
Abstract: This thesis studies the textual productions of students in the last stage of elementary school in contest condition with the objective of analyzing the relationship between the discourse on the teaching of writing, understood as the set of didactic methodologies provided for in official documents, and the constitution of a subject of the student-competitor, conceived as an ideological effect produced by the historical insertion of the student in a didactic tradition. Based on the Discourse Analysis introduced by Pecheux (2014; 2015) and expanded by Courtine (2014) and the discussions on education, teaching and text production proposed by Larossa (2004), Comenius (2001), Bourdieu and Passeron (1992) , Apple (1979; 2001), Geraldi (1984; 1991), Gnerre (1992), Fabiano-Campos (2011) and Fairchild (2012), the teaching of writing that takes textual/discursive genres as objects of teaching is problematized, since there are indications that this contemporary practice nourishes and is nourished by discourses that, reproducing ancient conceptions, have become a supposed consensus. This would allow, in the face of official pedagogical guidelines, the emergence of gendering, a didacticism that is equally current (discursive event) and always already said (discursive memory). Reading statements (PECHEUX, 2016) and formulations, associating syntactic form and lexicalsemantic content (COURTINE, 2014), compared to 43 (forty-three) written essays allows us to interpret, based on the analysis of writing modes of the subject-competitors, the functioning of the neoliberal discursive formation materialized in official documents. The analysis of the texts allows to identify a tendency of incorporation of the technical control in the process of production of classes through the embedding of the competence (object of learning) codified in the exercise proposed in the classroom, marked by the systematicity and by the reintroduction, under the label of gendering, of reproduction rituals, an amalgamation that contrasts with Bakhtinian dialogism. The analysis of the texts allows us to identify a tendency towards the incorporation of technical control over the subject-competitor's saying, marked by systematicity and by the reintroduction, under the label of gendering, of reproduction rituals, an amalgamation that contrasts with Bakhtinian dialogism. In relation to the constitution of the subject, there are movements that indicate a certain adherence to themes of neoliberal discourse while there are occurrences of contrastive oscillations that approach differentiation procedures, indicating an attempt to work by the subject-competitor.
Author: Guimarães, Geová Bezerra
Language: Portuguese
Subfield: Education
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Keywords: writing instruction, didactic discourse, neoliberalism in education, gendering, didacticism, discursive formations, Bakhtinian dialogism, technical control, discursive memory, didactic tradition, elementary school students, writing modes, textual genres, subject constitution, ideology in education
SDG: Quality education
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7120616632
