Reporter Discrepancies in the Associations Between Mental Health Concerns and School Discipline
Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: Objective The Adolescent Brain Cognitive Development℠ (ABCD) Study, which follows more than 11,000 adolescents, provides a unique opportunity to examine the causes and consequences of school detentions and suspensions. Although school records are considered the gold standard for assessing disciplinary events, they are not available in the ABCD Study®. Instead, youth and caregivers provide single-item reports of past-year discipline that may differ in scope and severity. The current study explored whether prospective associations with future school discipline varied by reporter, focusing on prior-year adolescent mental health concerns and discipline history as predictors. Method Data from the ABCD Study (baseline n=9,772; 8-11 years of age; 52% male) were analyzed using linear mixed-effects models with multiple imputation. Multi-informant mental health concerns (externalizing, inattention/impulsivity, and internalizing) from the first follow-up wave predicted discipline over the next 2 years across 4 discipline-reporting groups: youth-reported (20%), caregiver-reported (13%), agreement (10%), and either reporter (24%). Results Youth-reported and either-reporter discipline measures showed higher prevalence rates but weaker bivariate associations with prior mental health and disciplinary history relative to caregiver-reported and agreement discipline measures; however, most differences diminished after covariate adjustment. Across reporters, prior discipline remained the strongest predictor of future discipline. Conclusion Reporter choice in school discipline measurement influenced observed associations. Patterns suggested that youth-reported discipline may capture a broad range of infractions, whereas caregiver-reported discipline may reflect more severe events. However, recognizing the limited precision of single-item discipline indicators is essential for interpreting results and guiding future ABCD investigations. Plain language summary This study evaluated how children's mental health and past experiences with school discipline impacted their chances of getting disciplined again. Utilizing data from the Adolescent Brain Cognitive Development℠ (ABCD) Study (n = 9,772, aged 8-11 years), the authors found that while demographics can increase disciplinary risk, they do not fully account for discrepancies between youth and caregiver discipline reporting. This study also found that teacher-reported inattention/impulsivity showed the largest effect on subsequent discipline. Adolescents who received school discipline were at higher risk for repeated discipline independent of demographic characteristics and prior behavioral concerns. Consistent with prior studies, these results suggest that school discipline is not an effective strategy for reducing behavioral problems in schools.
Source: JAACAP Open
Institutions: Florida International University, University of Delaware
Language: English
Subfield: Education
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: gold
Estimated APC paid: $2,600
Awards: G1552166202, 9/21 ABCD-USA CONSORTIUM: RESEARCH PROJECT SITE AT U MICHIGAN, 20/21 ABCD-USA CONSORTIUM: RESEARCH PROJECT SITE AT VCU, 3/21 ABCD-USA CONSORTIUM: RESEARCH PROJECT SITE AT U MINNESOTA, 7/21 ABCD-USA CONSORTIUM: RESEARCH PROJECT SITE AT YALE, 17/21 ABCD-USA CONSORTIUM: RESEARCH PROJECT SITE AT UCLA, 15/21 ABCD-USA Consortium: Research Project Site at LIBR, 16/21 ABCD-USA CONSORTIUM: RESEARCH PROJECT SITE AT UNIVERSITY OF ROCHESTER, 8/21 ABCD-USA CONSORTIUM: RESEARCH PROJECT SITE AT CHLA, ABCD-USA Consortium: Coordinating Center, 6/21 ABCD-USA CONSORTIUM: RESEARCH PROJECT SITE AT OHSU, 10/21 ABCD-USA CONSORTIUM: RESEARCH PROJECT SITE AT SRI, 12/21 ABCD-USA CONSORTIUM: RESEARCH PROJECT SITE AT U PITTSBURGH, 19/21 ABCD-USA CONSORTIUM: RESEARCH PROJECT SITE AT UVM, 1/21 ABCD-USA CONSORTIUM: RESEARCH PROJECT SITE AT U UTAH, 11/21 ABCD-USA Consortium: Research Project Site at UWM, School Discipline and Adolescent Health: The Role of Early Adversity and Neurodevelopment, ABCD-USA Consortium: Data Analysis, Informatics and Resource Center, 21/21 ABCD-USA CONSORTIUM: RESEARCH PROJECT SITE AT WUSTL, 13/21 ABCD-USA CONSORTIUM: RESEARCH PROJECT SITE AT MUSC, 5/21 ABCD-USA Consortium: Research Project Site at UC San Diego, 18/21 ABCD-USA CONSORTIUM: RESEARCH PROJECT SITE AT THE UNIVERSITY OF FLORIDA, 2/21 ABCD-USA CONSORTIUM: RESEARCH PROJECT SITE AT UMB, 14/21 ABCD-USA Consortium: Research Project Site at CU Boulder
OpenAlex ID: W7123350252
