One-on-one Supervision: Critical Insights Into Relationality
Year: 2025
Type: article
Abstract: The one-on-one supervision model is often criticised as hierarchical and outdated. This article reimagines this model in a context where rigour and empathy can coexist. It examines how the supervisory relationships can, in themselves, enable learning, academic identity development, and transformational growth. Drawing on narrative reports from three former PhD students, we examine critical incident insights that shaped their doctoral journeys. Their examples are central to their growth and demonstrate the strength of a one-on-one supervision model rooted in empathy, attentiveness, and respect for one another. The research adopts an interpretive perspective, using subjective meaning-making and experiential knowing as sufficient epistemological frameworks. The results show that good supervision is more than transactional or procedural in nature; rather, it is fundamentally relational and developmental. Relationality encapsulates the continuous development of identity that occurs throughout the doctoral journey. We argue that the aim of doctoral supervision needs to be more than merely completing the thesis.
Authors: H Namakula, M Keane
Language: English
Subfield: Education
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
SDG: Quality education
Open Access status: hybrid
OpenAlex ID: W7127038481
