Work

Problems of observing reasonable time limits in cases concerning the determination of a child’s place of residence

Year: 2025
Type: article
Abstract: The article is devoted to a comprehensive analysis of the problems related to ensuring the reasonableness of time limits in cases concerning the determination of a child’s place of residence. The study demonstrates that prolonged proceedings in such disputes directly affect the psychological well-being of the child, intensify parental conflict, and create risks of violating the principle of the child’s best interests. Taking into account the provisions of the Constitution of Ukraine, the Civil Procedure Code of Ukraine, ECtHR practice, and the positions of national judicial institutions, the article identifies the criteria for assessing a “reasonable time” and the factors that most frequently cause delays: the complexity of the case, passivity or abuse of procedural rights by the parties, excessive workload of courts, lengthy expert examinations, and insufficient coordination with state authorities and child-protection bodies. Particular attention is paid to the impact of martial law, which has introduced additional challenges such as the displacement of children and families, staff shortages, limited access to documents, and a significant increase in the workload of courts due to changes interritorial jurisdiction. Based on an analysis of judicial practice, including case No. 202/2883/22, the study highlights systemic organizational and procedural issues that cause delays in opening proceedings, sending correspondence, and scheduling hearings. It is argued that the absence of special legislative guarantees for expedited consideration of family cases leads to inconsistency in time frames and violations of the principle of legal certainty. The author proposes improving procedural regulation, including establishing clear time limits for preparing the full text of court decisions, introducing mechanisms for monitoring compliance with these deadlines, and developing accelerated procedures for disputes involving children. The article emphasizes the need to strengthen inter agency cooperation, digitalize communication between the court and participants in the process, and implement unified standards for assessing time limits infamily disputes. It concludes that comprehensive reform of procedural mechanisms and strengthening the institutional capacity of the judicial system are necessary to ensure prompt and effective protection of the child’s rights.
Language: English
Subfield: Law
Open Access status: diamond
OpenAlex ID: W7127075976
FWCI: 1.321
Cites:
Cited by: 1
Related to: 9