Genesis of the concept of “dispute” in international law
Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: The article examines the evolution of the concept of “dispute” in international law – from the pragmatic approach embodied in the Hague Conferences of 1899 and 1907 and in the draft international legal instruments of the League of Nations, to the formulation and further development of the “Mavrommatis formula” in the jurisprudence of the Permanent Court of International Justice and the International Court of Justice (ICJ). It is demonstrated that early international treaties and doctrinal sources operated with related but non-unified terms (“dispute,” “conflict,” “differences,” etc.), deliberately avoiding a precise definition. A decisive stage in the conceptual formation of the term “dispute” was the emergence of the Mavrommatis formula, according to which a dispute is understood as “a disagreement on a point of law or fact, a conflict of legal views or interests.” The ICJ further developed the Mavrommatis formula in its subsequent judgments, expanding its meaning and identifying several additional features of a dispute: the objective existence of a disagreement; the necessity of a mutual opposition of positions; the specificity and determinacy of the dispute’s subject matter; the “birth” of a dispute at the moment when one party’s claim meets the other’s refusal or objection; independence from the form of expression – i.e., the existence of a dispute does not require that the parties’ positions be expressed in writing, as they may be implicit or inferred from conclusive conduct; and the criterion of a “clearly expressed contestation,” which implies not a merely perceived divergence of interests but a genuine conflict of legal positions articulated through a claim and its rejection. Based on an analysis of international judicial practice and legal doctrine, the author identifies the elements that confer an international character upon a dispute: participation of subjects of international law; a subject matter governed by international law; crystallization and mutual recognition (or objective establishment) of claims; and the coincidence of the object and subject of the dispute in the mutual demands of the parties. The article examines the relationship between the concepts of “dispute,” “conflict,” and “situation,” as well as the traditional division into “legal” and “political” disputes, which is subjected to critical reassessment. The author proposes the following definition of an “international dispute”: precisely formulated (crystallized), mutually acknowledged or objectively established differences arising under international law in relations between subjects of international law (the parties to the dispute) due to their disagreement on questions of law or fact, a conflict of legal positions or interests concerning clearly defined object and subject of the dispute, which coincide in the mutual claims of the parties. The study concludes that clarity in the definition and classification of disputes directly enhances the effectiveness of their peaceful settlement and reduces the risk of escalation.
Author: M.O. Kononenko
Institution: V. N. Karazin Kharkiv National University
Language: English
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: diamond
OpenAlex ID: W7127078939
