Work

Criminal-law counteraction to torture in foreign states of different legal families: a comparative-law perspective

Year: 2025
Type: article
Abstract: The article is dedicated to a comprehensive comparative-law study of criminal-law measures against torture in states belonging to the Romano-Germanic and Anglo-American legal families, aiming to develop optimal guidelines for the improvement of Ukrainian legislation. The focus is placed on the analysis of legislative constructions of the elements of torture, the determination of its object, objective and subjective characteristics, as well as the specifics of the perpetrator in different jurisdictions. It is demonstrated that countries of the continental legal tradition exhibit a wide range of models of criminalization: from detailed, multi-tiered definitions of torture (Spain) to the absence of a direct statutory norm and reliance on international instruments (Germany, partially France). In French law, emphasis is placed not only on violations against health but also on honor, dignity, and will, although a formal legal definition of torture is lacking, which has prompted observations by international institutions. In German law, torture is characterized by the presence of specially designated victims. Spanish legislation demonstrates the approach most closely aligned with international standards, explicitly defining all key elements of torture, including the mandatory special purpose and a special perpetrator. In Anglo-American legal systems, the central elements are the presence of a special perpetrator and the focus on inflicting severe physical or psychological suffering without the necessity of a special purpose. United Kingdom law considers both acts and omissions as constituting torture and recognizes the tacit consent of an official as a form of complicity. U.S. legislation provides a detailed definition of psychological suffering and criminalizes conspiracy to commit torture. The comparative analysis shows that despite the diversity of models, all legal systems share the understanding of torture as an encroachment on fundamental human values – health, honor, dignity, will, and, in certain cases, life. It is established that for Ukraine, the most effective approach is a combination of a clear normative construction of the elements of torture, harmonized with international instruments, with the simultaneous assurance of the practical effectiveness of the prohibition. Based on the study of foreign experience, the article concludes on the necessity of further modernization of national legislation, including clarification of the elements of the offense, strengthening guarantees for victims, and ensuring law-enforcement practices capable of preventing both direct and covert forms of torture in contemporary conditions.
Language: English
Open Access status: diamond
OpenAlex ID: W7127097808
FWCI:
Cites: 1
Cited by:
Related to: 9