Work

Life Projects in High School: How Does Teachers’ Content Management Influence Students’ Positive Development? (Qualitative Bias)

Year: 2025
Type: preprint
Abstract: The Brazilian high school curriculum has undergone significant changes in recent years. One of these changes is the introduction of the Life Project Curriculum Component (LPCC), which has sparked widespread discussion. The increasing use of the term 'Life Project' (LP) in the educational context is accompanied by significant ambiguity and a lack of conceptual clarity. Review studies have identified that many scientific publications either do not define LP or do so in a limited manner (Coscioni et al., 2024; Dellazzana-Zanon & Freitas, 2015). According to Coscioni (2021), such conceptual confusion may lead to professional practices without proper scientific grounding. The Comprehensive Theory of Life Projects (CTLP; Coscioni et al., 2023) offers a theoretical and practical framework aimed at understanding the complexity of the term LP. From a theoretical perspective, it integrates knowledge from different fields. From a practical perspective, it has recently been translated into six guiding axes for professional practice. Therefore, the CTLP has relevant implications for the teaching work in the LPCC. In the Brazilian scientific literature, opinions on the LPCC are divided. In education, various studies are mostly essayistic, with little systematized empirical evidence. Their conclusions often critique the teaching materials and state curricular proposals for the LPCC (Silva & Morais, 2022; Cássio & Goulart, 2022), reinforcing the connection between the LPCC and neoliberal ideology (Macedo & Silva, 2022). In psychology, there are more empirical studies, using correlational quantitative methods (Toledo et al., 2021) and interviews with teachers (Silva et al., 2023). Most studies adopt a cross-sectional approach, with findings describing relationships between individual variables and LP, as well as retrospective accounts of teachers’ experiences and conceptions regarding the LPCC. The literature still lacks studies that systematically evaluate the LPCC using robust research designs, such as longitudinal panels or direct observations in class. In the international context, the term LP is recognized as an important outcome of career counseling and other psychological interventions (Di Fabio et al., 2019). Therefore, understanding the process of constructing LPs within the framework of a large-scale educational policy, such as the LPCC in Brazil, offers valuable insights for both researchers and practitioners worldwide. Examining how a national curriculum integrates LPs into formal schooling can contribute to global discussions on career education, youth development, and educational equity. Moreover, Brazil’s diverse social and economic landscape provides a unique context to explore how LP-related interventions function across different student populations, shedding light on potential challenges, best practices, and scalable models that could inform similar initiatives in other countries. This study will investigate the teaching work developed in the LPCC, particularly teachers’ content management while planning and teaching in this curricular component in public state schools of Rio Grande do Sul, Brazil (RS/BR). The proposal for the life project curriculum component has been organized by the Secretary of Education of Rio Grande do Sul (SEDUC/RS). The central question of this research is: What relationships can be established between recontextualizations of the SEDUC/RS proposal for the Life Project Curriculum Component carried out by secondary school teachers and the contributions of lessons in this component to students' integral education? Contrary to the criticisms raised by educational scholars regarding the LPCC, the initial premise of this project is that properly grounded teaching work can generate positive effects on young people's lives. Specifically, it is assumed that aligning teaching practices with the guiding principles of the CTLP will lead to changes in students’ positive development. Thus, this study will not only provide practical contributions but also advance the theoretical understanding of LP as a concept. To address the research question, a mixed-method study will be implemented. Quantitative data will be collected through a longitudinal panel, while qualitative data will be gathered through interviews, classroom observations, and focus groups. Analyzing teaching practices from multiple sources may provide deeper insight into the actual effects of the LPCC on young people's lives. Consequently, this study offers insights that can inform educational policy and teaching practices, with implications beyond the Brazilian context. This pre-registration is due to the qualitative focus of this mixed-methods study.
Language: English
Subfield: Education
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7128401969
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: 10