Year: 2025
Type: article
Abstract: B a c k g r o u n d . The rapid adoption of chatbots in legal services has created new opportunities for improving access to justice, while simultaneously raising unresolved questions about risks, accountability, and regulatory oversight. Recent initiatives illustrate the potential of these tools to reduce costs, overcome geographical barriers, and provide timely guidance to self-represented litigants. Yet the same features that make chatbots attractive-instant availability, natural language fluency, and apparent expertise-also magnify dangers: misinformation, bias, breaches of confidentiality, and impacts on due process. Against this background, this paper asks what regulatory and self-regulatory measures are necessary to ensure that legal chatbots deliver accurate, fair, and rights-compliant assistance. M e t h o d s . The study employs a structured, multi-stage methodology. It begins by defining "legal chatbot" and classifying them along a functional continuum from informational to advisory and rights-reporting systems. This typology enables a risk- based assessment of harms. Using access to justice as an evaluative lens, the analysis then examines benefits and vulnerabilities through indicators drawn from the WJP Rule of Law Index. Evidence is synthesized from case law, academic studies, and professional reports, and benchmarked against regulatory frameworks such as the EU AI Act, the GDPR, and Council of Europe instruments, supplemented by national guidelines and emerging professional standards. R e s u l t s . Findings show that legal chatbots range from low-risk informational assistants to high-risk advisory tools directly affecting fundamental rights. While informational chatbots primarily require transparency and update obligations, advisory and rights-reporting systems demand stronger safeguards, including verification, human oversight, and liability mechanisms. Existing regulation provides partial coverage but remain too general or fragmented, leaving significant governance gaps. C o n c l u s i o n s . The paper concludes that a hybrid model is required: binding regulatory measures to anchor transparency, accountability, and data protection, coupled with self-regulatory initiatives from bar associations and courts to guide professional responsibility. Collaborative oversight among developers, regulators, and professional bodies is essential to balance innovation with accountability. Ultimately, legal chatbots can enhance access to justice, but only if governed by proportionate frameworks that safeguard fairness, due process, and public trust.
Authors: Nataliia MAZARAKI, Tamara KORTUKOVA
Institution: State University of Trade and Economics
Language: English
Subfield: Law
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: diamond
OpenAlex ID: W7130833389
