Work

Can Seismic Wave Speeds and Attenuation Detect Water in the Martian Crust?

Year: 2025
Type: dissertation
Abstract: Seismic data recorded by NASA’s InSight mission provided the first direct imaging of Mars’ crust. Several one-dimensional seismic velocity models have been published since then; however, interpreting these models in terms of lithology and the presence or absence of liquid water or ice remains challenging due to the limited geophysical constraints. While some models suggest a fully saturated crust, a more plausible scenario is that Mars’ crust contains small volumes of liquid water or vapor. Another key observation is that seismic recordings from marsquakes lack the strong surface waves commonly observed on Earth. In this thesis, I aim to explore why seismic recordings on Mars exhibit weak surface waves and, as we probe deeper into the crust, what lithologies and pore water/ice contents are consistent with the seismic velocity models derived from InSight data. First, I investigate seismic wave propagation on Mars using the spectral element method. These models are constructed based on published subsurface velocity and structural data, along with real Martian topography. Our results show that impact craters, abundant across Mars, significantly scatter surface waves, while having minimal effect on body waves. We propose that the absence or weakness of surface waves observed in Mars seismic recordings is at least partially, if not entirely, due to scattering from impact craters and potentially also from their underlying fractured and damaged zones. Second, I investigate the effects of humidity and temperature on a poorly consolidated sandstone, used here as an analogue for sedimentary rocks in the Martian crust. To conduct this study, I developed a custom cryo-vessel for laser ultrasonic measurements. Seismic waveforms were recorded using a laser ultrasonic system with the rock sample enclosed in a chamber where the relative humidity was controlled between 15% and 90%, and temperatures reached as low as –7◦C. The results show that P-wave velocity decreases by approximately 30% at 90% relative humidity compared to 15% RH at room temperature. A relationship between water volume mixing ratio and P-wave velocity is established, and extrapolation of this relationship suggests that seasonal variations in Mars’ atmospheric humidity could induce velocity changes comparable to those observed a few meters beneath the InSight lander. In contrast, temperature has a significantly smaller effect on P-wave velocity than humidity (∼5% at 10% humidity within our temperature range). For humidity greater than 30%, the observed velocity changes at lower temperatures are largely attributed to increased humidity via condensation. Using a contact-cement model, we interpret that ice formed under varying humidity conditions likely deposits away from grain contacts, rather than at the contacts themselves. Third, we investigate the effects of humidity and temperature on the seismic velocity and attenuation of two basalt samples, a rock type commonly found in Mars’ crust. Laser ultrasonic experiments reveal that humidity reduces P-wave velocity and increases wave attenuation in the high-porosity basalt. Additionally, we find that the high-porosity sample is more sensitive to humidity changes than the low-porosity sample. Consistent with the sandstone experiments, temperature has a minimal effect on both seismic velocity and attenuation. We qualitatively assess the factors contributing to humidity-induced attenuation and interpret that fluid movement and grain contact line dynamics are the primary mechanisms controlling this phenomenon. Lastly, we interpret Mars’ seismic data from previous studies in light of our laboratory results, with a focus on crustal seismic velocity models and the implications for scattering in the shallow crust. This study offers geophysical constraints and new insights into the lithology and pore-filling materials of the shallow Martian crust.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7135299232
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: 10