Work

Review of: "Human Artistic Discernment as an Evaluative Criterion in the Age of Artificial Intelligence"

Year: 2026
Type: peer-review
Abstract: This manuscript addresses a timely and intellectually engaging question: how should human artistic discernment be conceptualised and positioned in relation to AI-based evaluative systems?The paper proposes a dual framework in which artistic discernment is treated, rst, as a philosophically distinctive human capacity grounded in contextual interpretation, value-based reasoning, and ethical re ection, and, second, as a form of judgment whose observable outcomes may be partially examined through statistical tools.This overall ambition is clear in the abstract and introduction, and the manuscript's central thesis is coherent at a broad conceptual level.The topic is important, and the attempt to defend a meaningful role for human judgment in AI-mediated environments is worthwhile.However, in its current form, the manuscript has substantial conceptual, methodological, and presentational weaknesses.Most importantly, the paper moves too quickly from a philosophical defence of discernment to empirical-sounding claims that are not adequately supported by the illustrative material presented.The manuscript would bene t from a clearer positioning either as a conceptual paper with a methodological illustration or as an empirical paper with genuine data and fully speci ed analyses.
Source: Qeios
Language: English
Open Access status: diamond
OpenAlex ID: W7143331237
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: 10