Work

Mechanisms of Change and Facilitating Factors in Blended Care

Year: 2025
Type: dissertation
Abstract: Blended care (BC) integrates digital components with face-to-face (f2f) psychotherapy and has been proposed as a promising approach to improve access, flexibility, and continuity of mental health care. While a growing body of research suggests that BC can achieve outcomes comparable to or better than traditional psychotherapy, considerably less is known about how therapeutic change unfolds in BC and which mechanisms are involved. Addressing this gap is essential for the informed development, implementation, and evaluation of blended interventions. This dissertation investigates mechanisms of change and facilitating factors in BC, with a particular focus on therapeutic alliance, self-efficacy, therapeutic agency, and empowerment. Across four empirical studies, the dissertation combines different study designs: participatory intervention development, systematic review and meta-analysis, longitudinal modeling, and qualitative content analysis. Study 1 used a participatory design approach to develop a blended intervention (TONI). Through interviews, focus groups, and iterative prototyping with patients and therapists, the study identified facilitators and barriers for BC implementation. Findings highlighted the importance of transparency, usability, and flexible alignment with patient needs, as well as concerns regarding workload, data security, and potential impacts on the therapeutic relationship. These insights informed the design of TONI, a transtheoretic and transdiagnostic BC intervention to be used in routine outpatient psychotherapy. Study 2 synthesized existing evidence on self-efficacy as a mechanism of change in internet-based interventions, including blended formats, using a systematic review and meta-analysis. Across 41 randomized controlled trials, digital interventions showed small to moderate positive effects on self-efficacy. Evidence for self-efficacy as a predictor of outcomes was mixed, while it emerged as a potential mediator. However, heterogeneity was high, and the methodological quality of mediator studies was largely insufficient. Study 3 examined longitudinal associations between therapeutic alliance, self-efficacy, and therapeutic agency and outcomes in blended versus routine outpatient psychotherapy. All constructs were associated with better outcomes. Temporal effects showed that increases in alliance, mental health self-efficacy, and agency predicted subsequent improvements in outcomes across both treatment formats. Differences in processes between BC and f2f psychotherapy were only found for general self-efficacy, suggesting that BC primarily mobilizes established therapeutic processes rather than distinct, format-specific patterns. Study 4 explored empowerment from the patient perspective using qualitative responses from a large outpatient sample. Patients described empowerment as a multidimensional experience encompassing increased everyday functioning, more effective coping strategies and a better self-concept. The factors patients perceived as contributing to empowerment, such as the therapeutic relationship, the structure of therapy and opportunities to apply strategies, partly overlapped with how empowerment itself was experienced. Digital components were rarely described as transformative but were perceived as supportive tools. Taken together, the findings suggest that BC draws on established therapeutic mechanisms rather than introducing fundamentally new processes. Digital components appear to support mechanisms such as alliance, self-efficacy, agency, and empowerment, without substantially altering their function. At the same time, variability in engagement, implementation, and measurement are methodological challenges in identifying mechanisms in BC. Future research should focus on mechanism-sensitive designs, implementation challenges, personalization strategies, and the careful integration of emerging technologies within BC.
Language: English
Field: Psychology
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7147599765
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: 10