Clinical Outcomes of Open, Tubular, and Endoscopic Lumbar Discectomy
Year: 2026
Type: article
Study design: Observational Study
Abstract: Study Design: Retrospective cohort study, level III evidence. Objective: Compare demographic characteristics and clinical outcomes among patients undergoing open microdiscectomy (OMD), tubular microdiscectomy (TMD), and full endoscopic discectomy (FED). Summary of Background Data: OMD remains the standard approach for lumbar disc herniation; however, minimally invasive and endoscopic techniques continue to gain popularity. Existing studies typically compare two approaches, with few evaluating all three within a single cohort. Furthermore, data describing outcomes in high-risk patients remains limited. Materials and Methods: Patients above 18 years old undergoing a primary, single-level OMD, TMD, or FED over a 7-year period at a tertiary medical center were included. Continuous variables were analyzed using Kruskal-Wallis tests with Dunn’s post hoc comparisons and categorical variables with χ 2 testing. Multivariate regression and generalized linear models identified predictors of negative outcomes [postoperative complications, revision, or related emergency department visits (EDV) within 1 yr]. Results: In total, 757 patients were included (422 OMD, 190 TMD, 145 FED). FED patients were older (50.1±15.7 yr, P =0.005) with a higher mean body mass index (30.4±6.5 kg/m 2 , P =0.04) and a greater proportion of American Anesthesiology Score (ASA) scores of III (33.9%, P <0.001). FED demonstrated the lowest estimated blood loss (EBL) (7.6 mL, P <0.001), shortest length of stay (LOS) (0.26 d, P <0.001), but with the longest operative time (107.5 min, P <0.001). Complication, revision, and EDV did not differ among the 3 techniques. Multivariate analysis identified the presence of an intraoperative dural tear (RR: 1.29, P =0.007) as predictive of negative outcomes. Conclusion: Endoscopic lumbar discectomies can be safely performed with minimal EBL and LOS; however, surgeries are often longer when compared with TMD and OMD. Lumbar FED is still an emerging technique with a significant learning curve; however, it may expand the availability of surgical procedures to patients who may not have been surgical candidates otherwise.
Source: Spine Open
Authors: Dillon H. Stone, Garrison P. Bentz, John O’Malley, Lane McCoy, Anshum Sood, Salim Yakdan, Camilo A. Molina, Jacob Buchowski, John C. Clohisy, Jacob K. Greenberg, Brian J. Neuman, Keith Bridwell, Blake K. Montgomery, Karan Joseph, Benjamin Plog, Lucas Budd, Pallavi Jonnalagadda, John Ogunlade, Mark J. Lambrechts
Institution: Washington University in St. Louis
Language: English
Subfield: Orthopedics and Sports Medicine
Field: Medicine
Domain: Health Sciences
Open Access status: hybrid
OpenAlex ID: W7148286643
