Does Carbon Pricing Outperform Command-and-Control Regulation? Firm-Level Evidence from Korea’s Dual Regulatory Framework
Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: This study compares the effects of carbon pricing and command-and-control regulation on firms’ environmental performance. I leverage a unique dual-policy setting in South Korea, where a carbon pricing scheme (the Emissions Trading Scheme, ETS) and a command-and-control program (the Target Management System, TMS) operate in parallel. Because each firm is regulated under only one of the two, the setting allows a direct comparison of the two approaches. Using a difference-in-differences design on firm-level panel data from 2011 to 2022, I find that firms that transitioned from the TMS to the ETS reduced energy use by 5.8% to 8.8% and carbon emissions by 7.3% to 8.5% relative to firms that remained under the TMS, while effects on carbon intensity were not robust. Because TMS firms were themselves subject to binding emissions targets, these estimates reflect the additional effect of carbon pricing over command-and-control regulation. The absence of a robust intensity effect indicates that the ETS reduced emissions without a measurable improvement in emissions efficiency. A phase-specific analysis further shows that the reductions were strongest in the more market-oriented phases of the ETS, which featured allowance auctioning and benchmark-based allocation. This suggests that jurisdictions transitioning from command-and-control regulation to carbon pricing can strengthen its effectiveness by phasing in auctioning and benchmark-based allocation rather than relying on free allocation.
Source: SocArXiv (OSF Preprints)
Author: Pyung Kim
Language: English
Subfield: Economics and Econometrics
Domain: Social Sciences
SDG: Climate action
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7159909005
