Beyond the Motherhood Role: Navigating Gendered Expectations, Stress, and Partnership Across the Maternal Experience
Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: Background and Significance The transition to motherhood and the subsequent parenting experience represent major and complex life transitions for women, involving significant physical, psychological, social, and occupational adjustments. While this process holds opportunities for growth, it also carries an increased risk of stress-related psychopathological symptoms (SRS), such as anxiety and depression. Societal factors, specifically internalized gender roles and the expectation of "intensive mothering" (EIM)- which demands that mothers be fully dedicated, child-centered, and emotionally available- can create immense pressure on women. While extensive research has addressed maternal stress, the mechanisms through which internalized gender role attitudes (GRA) and intensive mothering expectations translate into psychological distress remain underexplored. The partner's own gender role attitudes and their perceived parental support play a pivotal role in either buffering or exacerbating this distress. To map these complex pathways, this study utilizes the framework of Feminine Gender Role Stress (FGRS) to capture the subjective stress women experience when trying to meet these gendered expectations. Furthermore, the study examines these dynamics across two distinct maternal phases: the acute transition into early motherhood and the chronic, cumulative demands of established motherhood. To capture the full frame of maternal well-being, the research integrates key related constructs, including parenting stress, parental burnout, and the systemic challenges of work-family balance (WLB), alongside individual resilience factors such as psychological flexibility and parenting sense of competence (PSOC). Purpose of the Study The primary purpose of this study is to investigate how maternal and partner gendered expectations, gender role attitudes, intensive mothering ideologies, and resilience factors impact mothers' well-being among women in heteronormative long-term relationships. The project focuses on two distinct groups: women undergoing the transition to motherhood (3-12 months postpartum) and those in established motherhood (mothers of children aged 6-12). Specifically, the study aims to: 1. Examine the mediating role of Feminine Gender Role Stress (FGRS) in the relationship between maternal gender attitudes (GRA/EIM) and stress-related symptoms (SRS). 2. Evaluate the moderating role of the partner's involvement, support, and gender role attitudes in buffering or exacerbating maternal stress. 3. Analyze the impact of different motherhood contexts, comparing the acute stress of the maternal transition (first-time mothers, 3-12 months postpartum) with the daily stressors of established motherhood (mothers of school-aged children, ages 6-12), while incorporating parenting stress and parental burnout challenges. 4. Explore the subjective lived experiences of new mothers through a qualitative lens to deeply contextualize the quantitative findings. Research Design and Methodology This project employs a mixed-methods approach conducted across two studies to examine maternal experiences across different contexts: 1. Study 1 (Transition to Motherhood): Includes a quantitative phase consisting of an online cross-sectional survey (via Qualtrics) administered to a minimum of 150 first-time, cis-gendered mothers (over 18 years old, 3–12 months postpartum) and their heterosexual partners. These questionnaires assess demographic information, gendered and maternal attitudes, feminine gender role stress (FGRS), partner support, parenting sense of competence, psychological flexibility, and maternal stress-related symptoms. This is paired with a qualitative sub-study consisting of semi-structured interviews with a subset of mothers to deeply capture their subjective lived experiences. 2. Study 2 (Established Motherhood): Utilizes a quantitative cross-sectional survey focusing on a separate group of mothers with school-aged children (ages 6–12) to assess ongoing parenting stress. It employs the same core measures as Study 1, alongside additional assessments of parental burnout and parenting stress. Expected Outcomes This research aims to bridge key gaps in the literature by offering an integrated framework to understand how parenting stress, gender roles, and partner dynamics shape the maternal experience. The expected outcomes include: 1. Advancing the conceptualization of Feminine Gender Role Stress (FGRS) within motherhood to clarify how internalized societal expectations impact maternal mental health. 2. Highlighting the partner’s role- via both involvement and gender attitudes- as a key factor shaping the maternal experience within heteronormative couples, establishing a foundation for couple-focused interventions. 3. Enhancing the understanding of family environments that support optimal child development, given that maternal well-being directly influences children's emotional, social, and academic functioning.
Authors: Michal Tevet, Liat Helpman
Language: English
Subfield: Sociology and Political Science
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Keywords: intensive mothering, gender role attitudes, maternal stress, postpartum period, partner support, parental burnout, parental stress, work-family balance, psychological flexibility, parenting sense of competence, resilience, maternal well-being, gender expectations, transition to motherhood, mediating and moderating effects
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7166321354
