Fragmented data, global bias: A synthesis of quantitative research on the illicit trade in cultural objects
Year: 2026
Type: article
Study design: Systematic Review
Abstract: Academic research into the illicit trade in cultural objects has grown substantially over the last 50 years. Yet our understanding remains dominated by fragmentary evidence, repetitive methodologies, and one-sided narratives that can enable epistemic blind spots and sensationalised claims. Without a comprehensive understanding of the trade, how it has been studied, and by whom, such blind spots will continue to limit the development of effective countermeasures. This review provides an initial synthesis of English-language quantitative research on the trafficking and trade in antiquities, examining how this research has been produced, by whom, where, and with what methods. Using systematic searches of academic databases and key outlets, we identified 168 English-language studies that used quantitative methods. Beginning with the first identified source from 1983, this constitutes a relatively limited body of work across more than four decades. Findings show a small and siloed subfield: nearly half of publications are solo authored and co-author clusters are weakly connected. Methodological approaches have become more interdisciplinary and diverse over time, yet explicit engagement with research ethics remains rare. Most notably, first authors are overwhelmingly based in the Global North while empirical focus falls disproportionately on Global South contexts, with limited collaboration involving scholars located in the regions under study. The article demonstrates that research into the illicit trade in cultural objects remains shaped by Anglo-American paradigms. By mapping existing evidence and its gaps, we hope to foster more diverse and effective evidence-based countermeasures.
Language: English
Subfield: Archeology
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: hybrid
Estimated APC paid: $2,810
OpenAlex ID: W7166328487
