Comment on “Complete-Arch Implant Impression Precision: Digital vs Conventional Techniques”
Year: 2026
Type: letter
Abstract: Dear Editor-We read with great interest the study by Mart ınez-Marug an et al 1 evaluating the precision of 6 complete-arch implant impression techniques under in vivo conditions.The authors should be commended for addressing a clinically relevant issue using a repeated-measures design and for incorporating both conventional and digital workflows into a single comparative framework.The investigation contributes meaningful data regarding stereophotogrammetry and intraoral scanning performance in fully edentulous rehabilitation.Nevertheless, several methodological and translational considerations may influence the interpretation of the reported superiority of the photogrammetry-based approach.A major concern relates to the statistical architecture of the study and the handling of repeated measurements within a single biological environment.Although 60 impressions and 28 Euclidean distances per suprastructure generated a large number of observations, all measurements originated from 1 patient with identical implant distribution, soft tissue characteristics, salivary conditions, and occlusal morphology.This creates substantial clustering and pseudo-replication that may artificially narrow variance estimates and exaggerate statistical significance.The use of 1-way analysis of variance and pairwise testing without hierarchical modelling or intraclass correlation adjustment may therefore overestimate between-technique differences.2 In clinical implant prosthodontics, biologic variability across patients often exerts a stronger influence on impression accuracy than repeated measurements within the same arch configuration. 3 Consequently, the apparent precision advantage observed for the Precise Implant Capture photogrammetry (PIC) system may not translate proportionally into routine clinical populations with divergent ridge anatomy and implant angulations.Another important issue concerns the exclusive reliance on linear Euclidean distance analysis as the primary outcome variable.Complete-arch implant frameworks are affected not only by linear discrepancies but also by rotational distortion, angular deviation, and cumulative 3-dimensional strain distribution across the prosthetic span.4 Two impression techniques may exhibit comparable linear precision while producing substantially different rotational implant relationships that alter passive fit and screw preload behaviour.The absence of angular deviation analysis may therefore
Source: International Dental Journal
Language: English
Subfield: Oral Surgery
Field: Dentistry
Domain: Health Sciences
Open Access status: gold
Estimated APC paid: $2,550
OpenAlex ID: W7166350788
