Year: 2006
Type: article
Abstract: Courts are not alone in wielding the responsibility and power of constitutional interpretation.Congress and state legislatures, federal and state executive officers, and many others act to interpret the U.S. Constitution in their daily work, including police officers, public school officials, and local politicians.Our divided system of democratic governance affords an opportunity for dialogue among government officials and the electorate in a variety of forms as constitutional law evolves.Constitutional law should be formulated in an ongoing, long-term dialogue in which judges, legislators, and other constitutional actors participate actively in shaping our understanding of the Constitution's protections and limitations.'Rhetoric about judicial activism abounds in modem political campaigns.Bar associations and judicial organizations regularly voice concern about the need to protect judges from encroachments on judicial independence.Judicial independence is threatened from some quarters, as particular judges are targeted for unpopular decisions with death threats, through email or media campaigns, or by calls for recall or impeachment proceedings.For example, great furor and attention was generated by decisions of Judge Harold Baer in New York for criminal rulings perceived as protecting defendants too extensively.Judge Alfred Goodwin in California was lambasted by public officials and others for authoring the opinion striking "under God" from the Pledge of Allegiance, based on the court's reading of Establishment Clause precedent.Judicial independence is threatened systemically as well, through failure to provide sufficient funding for t Dean and Professor of Law, University of Dayton School of Law.I am grateful to the law review editors at Case Western Reserve for organizing this conference on judicial independence and extending me an invitation to speak with such an esteemed group of scholars.I For further descriptions of constitutional dialogue, see sources cited in Lisa A. Kloppenberg, Measured Constitutional Steps, 71 IND.L.
Source: Case Western Reserve law review
Author: Lisa A. Kloppenberg
Institution: Santa Clara University
Language: English
Subfield: Law
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7167394
