Work

The Problem of «Russia and Europe» before Westernism: On the Genesis of the Idea of Civilizational Divergence

Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: The subject of this research is the process of the idea of the civilizational divergence between Russia and Europe in Russian social and philosophical thought, which is expressed in the gradual change of ideas about the West and Russia’s place in world history. The research examines the transition from the perception of the Latin West as a religiously alien world in the Old Russian tradition to the understanding of Europe as a cultural and state model in the Petrine era. Special attention is paid to how Europe became an internal criterion for evaluating Russian society in the 18th century, creating the problem of cultural division and historical self-sufficiency. The subject of this research is the analysis of the transition from the mechanical borrowing of European forms to the philosophical formulation of the question of Russia’s historical path in the early 19th century, as well as the identification of the role of Westernism as a stage in the conceptualization of the accumulated contradiction between the European orientation and the search for Russia’s own civilizational foundation. The research methodology is based on historic-philosophical, socio-philosophical, and civilizational approaches. It uses historical-genetic, comparative-historical, hermeneutical, and systemic analysis methods, as well as a problem-chronological approach. These methods allow to examine the issue of «Russia and Europe» as a long-term process of shaping Russian civilizational identity and to trace the evolution of the image of Europe in Russian thought. The scientific novelty of the study lies in shifting the focus from the usual analysis of the dispute between Westernizers and Slavophiles to earlier forms of Russian self-assessment. The work shows that Westernization didn’t emerge suddenly, but rather as a result of the accumulated experience of religious, cultural, and historical comparisons between Russia and Europe. It’s also significant that Europeanization is viewed not only as a form of modernization, but also as a source of internal cultural tension that affected ideas about the state, society, and spiritual tradition. It’s concluded that the question of Europe has gradually become a way for Russian thought to reflect on its own independence, the limits of borrowing, historical responsibility, and the foundations of Russia’s national development. This approach provides a more accurate explanation of why the topic of Russia and Europe remains relevant not only for the history of Russian philosophy but also for the contemporary understanding of the country’s civilizational identity.
Language: English
Open Access status: diamond
OpenAlex ID: W7167478778
FWCI:
Cites: 4
Cited by:
Related to: 10