Participatory modelling research to support the validation and co-design of sustainable farming systems
Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: Participatory research approaches engage stakeholders to improve the relevance, credibility, and adoption of co-designed research. Here, we present a participatory model validation framework that integrates bottom-up co-design with top–down modelling to support early-career researchers in navigating biophysical model calibration and validation. The bottom-up processes begin with validating baseline farm systems by iteratively refining model inputs with farm data and stakeholder experience to ensure that model outputs are scientifically robust, credible, and legitimate. Researchers and end-users then co-design manifold interventions that address collective priorities, validating model outputs using the same process. Participatory model validation with stakeholders strengthens scientific rigour, supports co-design of demand-driven innovations, builds stakeholder trust in scientific frameworks, and fosters deeper shared understanding and mutual respect among participants. In parallel, a set of common interventions was applied using a top–down approach to enable standardised comparison across farms. We demonstrate this approach using seven Australian farms, operationalising bottom-up co-design of farm-specific interventions aimed at reducing greenhouse gas emissions, improving environmental and economic co-benefits, and reducing trade-offs, and top-down interventions to facilitate contrasts across production systems and agroecological regions. We show that bottom-up people-centric model validation co-creates interventions more conducive to adoption than top–down modelling, because enablers and barriers to adoption associated with the former are identified and overcome with end-users. We articulate key preconditions for successful participatory model validation, including regular and iterative dialogue between research teams and stakeholders, establishment of shared goals and study scope, careful selection of modelling and analytical frameworks, pairing experienced academics with early-career staff during stakeholder consultation, comparison of model outputs with empirical peer-reviewed literature to ensure credibility, clear distinction between interdisciplinary research and transdisciplinary application, and establishment of clear timelines. Embedding participatory co-design within a structured transdiciplinary framework provides a practical approach for validating systems models using stakeholder knowledge under conditions where scientific datasets are often sparse.
Institution: University of Tasmania
Language: English
Subfield: Agronomy and Crop Science
Domain: Life Sciences
SDG: Climate action
Open Access status: gold
Estimated APC paid: $2,515
Award: G8808880447
OpenAlex ID: W7172531925
