Naturalist drawings vs photographs: How artistic representations shape visual exploration and aesthetic appreciation of marine biodiversity
Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: Public engagement with marine biodiversity is constrained by the inaccessibility of underwater ecosystems, limiting direct perceptual experience of these environments. Naturalist illustration, situated at the intersection of science and art, offers a visually informative representation of marine organisms, yet remains understudied in the context of visual attention and aesthetic reception. We compared 19th-century naturalist drawings with contemporary non-artistic photographs to examine their effects visual attention and aesthetic reception. Fifty-eight participants, including scuba divers and non-divers, observed 12 drawings or 12 photographs depicting comparable marine environments and species. Eye movements were recorded using eye-tracking, and aesthetic responses were assessed through a questionnaire. Naturalist drawings elicited significantly longer fixation durations, more fixations, and greater exploration than photographs, particularly among non-divers. Aesthetic reception varied according to both stimulus type and diving experience. Drawing was rated higher for artistic quality, while divers assigned higher expertise scores to photograph. Non-divers found drawing more attractive than divers, underscoring the value of naturalist art for broader audiences. Heat maps revealed that participants consistently focused on the eyes of depicted animals, including phylogenetically distant species such as crustaceans, suggesting similar attentional patterns across marine taxa. Overall, naturalist drawings enhance perceptual and aesthetic engagement with marine biodiversity. Integrating artistic representations into conservation outreach could enhance visual engagement and aesthetic appreciation of marine environments, which may be relevant for broader communication strategies.
Source: Biological Conservation
Language: English
Subfield: Cognitive Neuroscience
Field: Neuroscience
Domain: Life Sciences
SDG: Life below water
Open Access status: hybrid
Estimated APC paid: $3,830
OpenAlex ID: W7202033652
