Regulatory compliance does not fully capture riparian conservation status: evidence from a systematic review and a Chilean case study
Year: 2026
Type: review
Abstract: Riparian zones are vegetated areas adjacent to watercourses that provide critical ecosystem functions and are widely protected under environmental regulations to support soil, water, and biodiversity conservation. Across land uses, riparian vegetation is exposed to multiple anthropogenic pressures, increasingly amplified under global change. Despite extensive scientific literature and numerous methods for assessing riparian vegetation conservation, their standardization and integration with environmental regulations remain limited. We assessed how riparian conservation is evaluated globally, and how regulatory compliance relates to riparian vegetation conservation status in south-central Chile. We conducted a systematic literature review and a field-based assessment of 20 watercourse sites across native forests, forest plantations, and agricultural lands, integrating vegetation surveys, high-resolution drone imagery, the riparian forest quality index (QBR index) to assess riparian condition, and statistical analyses of vegetation patterns and regulatory compliance. Based on 129 reviewed studies, we identified 19 vegetation-based methods used globally to assess riparian conservation, dominated by the QBR (41.9%). Despite methodological dispersion, most approaches relied on field-based measurements. In the case study, riparian vegetation exhibited strong land use contrasts, with higher structural development and conservation status in native forests, intermediate conditions in forest plantations, and simplified riparian structure associated with lower conservation status in agricultural lands. At least 70% of the riparian sites met legal protection requirements; however, regulatory compliance was significantly associated with conservation status only in native forests ( ρ = 0.87), with weaker associations in forest plantations and agricultural lands. These findings demonstrate that buffer width-based regulations alone do not reliably reflect riparian vegetation conservation conditions. Our findings suggest that integrating vegetation-based indicators into regulatory frameworks could help align legal compliance with effective riparian conservation and restoration.
Source: Forest Ecosystems
Language: English
Subfield: Earth-Surface Processes
Field: Earth and Planetary Sciences
Domain: Physical Sciences
SDG: Life on land
Open Access status: gold
Estimated APC paid: $1,000
OpenAlex ID: W7203965511
