Untangling Pedagogy: A participatory action research study focused on unsettling patterns of exclusion and codesigning more inclusive futures for higher education
Year: 2026
Type: dissertation
Abstract: Educational designs reinforce hegemonic norms, which creates experiences of exclusion. This work aimed to explore how these norms and experiences of exclusion are constructed through sociomaterial entanglements, or networks of human and non-human actors, to reimagine the possibilities of educational design. The project was organized into two parts: revealing the present and re/shaping the future. In order to reveal the present, I invited students, staff, and faculty involved in higher education to participate in critical storytelling, sharing their experiences of exclusion, inclusion and inclusive practice through interviews. From the stories of exclusion, I created sociomaterial maps, string figures, to reveal how exclusion was constructed and then identified sociomaterial agents that contributed to these experiences and to shaping pedagogical practices. The second part of the study was structured as Critical Participatory Action Research drawing on codesign and emergent strategy frameworks. Interviewees from part 1 were invited to participate in a multi-month codesign project to imagine how higher education could be more inclusive and to design something to support this imagining at both a global and local scale. The outcome of the codesign was the development of Desire Path Pedagogy, an approach to teaching and learning that allows learners to choose their own paths through educational spaces and contribute to curricular design. The process of codesign also offered intriguing insights into fostering conversations and collective action within diverse groups. Multiple themes emerged from the stories, outputs of the codesign, and experience of codesign facilitation around how to support inclusive praxis and the challenges that may persist. Keywords: sociomaterialism, codesign, inclusive pedagogy, educational imaginaries, hegemonic norms, situated knowledges, emergence, care, empathy,
Source: TSpace (University of Toronto)
Author: Dilkes, Danielle
Institution: University of Toronto
Language: English
Subfield: Education
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7204015497
