Year: 2026
Type: book-chapter
Abstract: Chapter 5 focuses on immigration and the massive politicization of questions of integration and the borders of the community of solidarity. This challenge stands out by its relatively limited fiscal significance and the tremendous political polarization that characterizes the topic especially in continental and Northern Europe. Hence, questions of inclusion versus segmentation in the welfare state should be strongly and explicitly politicized between the Left-libertarian spectrum and the Radical Right. This divide between inclusive and segmenting approaches to the immigration challenge is supposed to cut right through both the Left (being torn between inclusive reforms or protective segmentation/welfare chauvinism) and the Right (being torn between targeted inclusion and segmentation). This chapter makes three important contributions to the literature on immigration and the welfare state. First, it demonstrates against much of the political and even academic debate that welfare chauvinism is unlikely to be the ‘dominant strategy’. Given the preferences and the numerical size of the New Left and the market-liberal Right, targeted inclusion is at least as likely a reform strategy, a finding that it illustrates through a comparative analysis of Germany and Sweden. Second, it shows that the Right is today much more divided on questions of welfare and immigration than the Left, which largely prioritizes inclusive reforms—even among most electorates and parties of the Old Left. Third, and consequently, moderate right-wing parties have a pivotal role to play in steering welfare state adaptation towards either inclusive or segmenting reforms.
Source: Oxford University Press eBooks
Language: English
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: hybrid
OpenAlex ID: W7204128372
