Work

Calibrated synthetic consumer panels for governed strategic market testing

Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: Generative artificial intelligence can rapidly generate large volumes of synthetic consumer-like responses. Yet, managers still lack robust rules for determining when such evidence is reliable enough to inform strategic market decisions. This study develops contextual residual calibration (CRC), a governance-oriented framework that treats synthetic personas as potentially biased measurement signals rather than substitutes for human consumers. Using a seed-locked Monte Carlo proof-of-concept, we evaluate six research designs across 500 simulated campaigns, 24 product concepts, six attributes, and four unequally sized consumer segments. The hybrid design combines 2,400 synthetic personas with 120 simulated human-validation observations under an anchored logistic correction model. Relative to synthetic-only estimation, uniform CRC reduces aggregate purchase-probability error by 53.8%, increases correct concept selection from 73.2% to 85.6%, and lowers simulated decision regret by 74.0%. Under an illustrative scenario assumption assigning each synthetic persona a cost weight of 0.02 relative to 1.00 for a simulated human respondent, the hybrid uses 80% fewer simulated human respondents and produces a 72% lower sampling-cost index than the 600-observation benchmark. These values are scenario-specific and should not be interpreted as universal estimates of real-world cost savings. These findings provide simulation-based proof-of-concept evidence for CRC as a governed augmentation framework, while external validation using actual LLM outputs, real consumers and observed market outcomes remains necessary.
Language: English
Open Access status: hybrid
OpenAlex ID: W7204199625
FWCI: 6.112
Cites: 31
Cited by: 2
Related to: 10