Personalising Cognitive Behavioural Therapy for Chronic Pain using person-specific Network Analysis and Single-Case Experimental Design
Year: 2026
Type: dissertation
Abstract: Cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT) is guideline-recommended for chronic pain, and its moderate effect sizes have been established at the group level. To enhance treatment outcomes, a shift from symptom-focused treatment towards targeting key psychological processes, alongside increasing efforts towards personalisation, have been advocated. The aim of this dissertation was threefold: 1) to develop and evaluate a measurement instrument for the longitudinal assessment of key psychological processes in chronic pain, 2) to derive personalised treatment recommendations based on these assessed processes, and 3) to propose and examine the feasibility and acceptability of an integrative framework combining process-oriented personalisation based on modern research methods for practitioners and individuals seeking treatment. Across four studies, the comprehensibility, relevance, and initial comprehensiveness of the newly developed item set was evaluated. In an online survey with n = 18 practitioners, items showed promising relevance and comprehensiveness. Subsequently, cognitive interviews with n = 12 individuals with chronic pain further supported the relevance, comprehensibility, and comprehensiveness and informed the revision of items with ambiguous ratings. The revised items were re-evaluated by n = 12 individuals with lived experience of chronic pain and n = 12 practitioners. In a fourth online study, n = 128 healthy individuals rated the overall comprehensibility of the item set positively with no significant added value of written and audio-visual comprehensibility aids. Overall, findings support the comprehensibility, relevance, and initial comprehensiveness of the item set. A pilot Ecological Momentary Assessment (EMA) study (six assessments per day over 12 days; n = 3 women undergoing treatment) indicated that participant burden was acceptable. In another EMA study (n = 68 individuals with lived experience; six assessments per day over 12 days; 4,236 observations), and a subsequent re-evaluation of revised items (n = 10 individuals in treatment; six assessments per day over 21 days; 1,253 observations), overall findings supported the reliability of the item set, with four of thirteen process scales missing the threshold for sufficient reliability. Variability analyses yielded mixed results: although all items met predefined variability criteria, intraclass correlation coefficients were larger than typically expected. Based on the revised item set, n = 22 interdisciplinary clinicians and n = 4 psychological pain researchers participated in a group Delphi study design and focus groups to develop a matching matrix linking two CBT modules to each process item. N = 15 clinicians from the first Delphi round contributed to the second round. The resulting matching matrix demonstrated robust first-choice module recommendations. Eight out of 23 second-choice module recommendations had to be discussed in the study team. All final decisions were based on the data. Finally, a proof-of-principle study was designed to study the feasibility and acceptability of an integrative framework combining 1) EMA and 2) person-specific network analysis to derive personalised treatment targets, 3) treatment recommendations for each target based on the matching matrix, and 4) a multiple baseline Single Case Experimental Design to monitor the treatment progress. N = 12 therapist-patient dyads completed the proof-of-principle study and participated in semi-structured interviews. The results suggest the procedure to be feasible and acceptable for both practitioners and therapists and revealed specific facilitators and obstacles to be considered in future research. Taken together, this dissertation combines several innovative methodological approaches to advance the personalisation of CBT for chronic pain. It is among the first to integrate process-orientation, data-informed clinical decision-making, and person-specific network analysis within the context of chronic pain. In the absence of established methodological gold standards, the work provides transparent rationales for key methodological decisions, thereby facilitating future research and replication. Individuals with lived experience, as well as expert clinicians and researchers, were involved across all stages of the research process, contributing to bridging the science-practice gap. The methodological decisions and findings of all studies are discussed in the light of current research. Alternative and complementary approaches are considered, and implications for future research and clinical practice are derived.
Author: Hofmann, Verena Eunike
Language: English
Field: Health Professions
Domain: Health Sciences
Keywords: chronic pain, cognitive behavioral therapy, personalization, network analysis, single-case experimental design, cognitive processes, scale development, ecological momentary assessment, treatment matching, Delphi method, cognitive interviewing, item comprehensibility, treatment acceptability, patient-reported outcomes, pain catastrophizing, fear avoidance, hopelessness, helplessness, catastrophizing
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7204265276
