Work

Sea surface temperature fingerprints fail to capture restoring dynamics of AMOC

Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: Sea-surface temperature (SST) fingerprints are widely used as indirect measures of Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation (AMOC) variability, including in assessments of AMOC stability. We test whether four such fingerprints preserve the local restoring behavior of directly simulated AMOC strength in 1,000 years of CESM2 preindustrial control output. Each of two AMOC indices and four SST fingerprints is analyzed as an independent time series. Seriesspecific delay and embedding dimension were selected to reconstruct the system’s state-space behavior, from which a model is fit for predicting how states evolve from one month to the next. The reconstruction allows us to explore the relationship between state-space location and prediction skill and to obtain the local restoring rate from the spectral radius of the model’s full Jacobian. Results show that a state-dependent forecast significantly improves one-month prediction for the 45◦N AMOC index yet all four SST fingerprints are best predicted by global linear models. Median restoring rates are 0.650 and 0.223 month−1 for AMOC at 26◦N and 45◦N, but only 0.028–0.079 month−1 for the SST fingerprints. One North Atlantic temperature fingerprint also exhibits state dependence in restoring rate relative to spectrum-and distribution-preserving surrogates (prange = 0.030), including behavior not reproduced by either direct AMOC index. Thus, an SST index can track AMOC-related variability without preserving the local dynamics required for AMOC stability inference. Plain-language summary Long direct observations of the Atlantic overturning circulation are not available, so sea-surface temperature patterns are often used as substitutes. Using a long climate-model simulation, we ask whether four temperature indices behave dynamically like two direct measures of the circulation. They do not. The direct circulation measures return toward their typical state substantially faster than the temperature indices. One widely used temperature definition also changes its apparent restoring behavior with temperature state in a way that is absent from the direct circulation measures. Temperature fingerprints may therefore remain useful indicators of AMOC-related variability, but they should not automatically be interpreted as measurements of AMOC stability.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7204458207
Cites: 27
Cited by:
Related to: 10